The Men's Leadership Community
THE MEN'S LEADERSHIP COMMUNITY
- For men seeking personal growth and heroic leadership at home and work
- For Men who are beat up, broken down & burned out from doing life alone.
Join a Brotherhood where Good Men become Heroic Leaders....at home, at work & in the world.
You can join the call live every Friday morning via Zoom @ 7:00am Central
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
The Men's Leadership Community
The Godly Thinking Man, Part 2: What Is Critical Thinking?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What actually is critical thinking and why does the enemy work so hard to keep men from it? In Part 2 of The Godly Thinking Man, hosts Andy and Obie go deep (and own that it’s academic on purpose): most men today are reactive, knee-jerk, and distracted and as C.S. Lewis warned, the devil doesn’t need to destroy you if he can just distract you.
Here’s the gut-punch: the critical problem isn’t that people don’t think, it’s that everyone thinks, and left to itself, our thinking is biased, distorted, and self-serving. The quality of your life, the guys argue, rises and falls on the quality of your thinking. And real critical thinking isn’t about being the smartest guy in the room, it starts with humility (“of course I’m a hypocrite - I’m a broken, sinful man”) and aims at something bigger: doing life well with other people, especially those who disagree with you.
In this episode we cover:
- Why men fear “thinking about their thinking” and make their opinions their identity
- The devil’s real strategy: distraction, the 15-second scroll, and letting AI think for you
- Everyone thinks, but biased, distorted thinking is the critical problem (James 3)
- Humility first: the disarming power of admitting “of course I’m a hypocrite”
- People aren’t projects - why Jesus asked questions instead of running a script
- The Bereans vs. the agitators: open-minded examination vs. rage-stirring
- A clear definition of critical thinking, and the sober mind Peter calls us to
Practical, funny, and convicting, this installment reframes critical thinking as spiritual maturity and whole-life wellness, solid food for mature men, not milk. You weren’t made to let a feed, a slogan, or an algorithm think for you.
The Men’s Leadership Community (MLC) is a Christ-centered brotherhood helping men move from surviving to thriving through discipleship, leadership, and authentic friendship. New episodes every Friday. Bring a friend. 🎧 themlc.life
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
Men. Welcome to the most important podcast that you'll hear in a long time. It's the Men's Leadership Community Podcast, and it starts now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this is a fairly academic, deeply academic conversation we're having as men over the next seven weeks. It is, there's no doubt. And some of you may be thinking, wow, why are we going so deep, kind of like on an academic conversation of what does it mean to be a thinking man? Well, I just look at the world around us right now, Obi. There are very few thinking men running around out there. There are a lot of reactive men, there are a lot of knee-jerk, you know, do what I say, not what I do, men out there. But there's not a lot of thinking men, and especially thinking men in Christ, like having the mind of Christ. So yeah, it's a little academic, Obi. It goes a little bit deeper, but that's the whole point is are you actually thinking about these things? And research says no, you know, less than 23% of people are actually thinking these thoughts going this deep. And why is it when we bring up a conversation of, hey, let's think a little bit deeper about our thinking, how we process things, how we make decisions. And what is the knee-jerk reaction of men in general, right? To go, okay, I'm out on that conversation. Why do we not want to think about our thinking, Obi? What do you, you know, what do you think one of the the main thing is? Let's just jump in on that question real quick before we even get to the events. Like, why do you guys kind of tune out when all of a sudden they're like, oh, we're gonna think about our thinking?
SPEAKER_06Mm-hmm. It's because then I believe it's gonna again, people, men in particular, are afraid of being open on us and vulnerable. And when we start talking about that, really it's gonna reveal things about you, right? And so that's that's gonna be that's really what what what I've found that keeps men from actually sharing their thoughts because now you're opening up and you're gonna get to take a peek behind the curtain. And you may not like what's behind the curtain because they don't like what's behind the curtain.
SPEAKER_02You know, and one of the things for me is what if I find out behind the curtain my that I'm that I'm wrong, my thinking is wrong. And yet, as a man, I'm so impassioned about the side that I that I find myself on, or of a conversation or an argument or whatever. And and you know what? I don't want to find out that I'm wrong because then I'll have to process why I'm wrong. Maybe I'll have to change the way I think about things when I don't think about my thinking and I know that I'm right, and I don't ever have to find out that I'm wrong, I can just stay there, you know? So at anyway, you know, I want I'd like some other guys maybe just to jump in real quick. You know, what do you guys think about that?
SPEAKER_06And Andy, and let me just say that this is why um a lot of times um when you disagree with somebody about something that that they've made their identity instead of thinking, that's why it it it they take it, they take it as an attack on who they are. Yes, because they they think that that's who they are, and they're not really thinking, they're just adopting something. And so when you say, I I don't know if I agree with that, and now you get you know the rest of the keyboard.
SPEAKER_02But what if all of a sudden we recognize that our identity is based on not thinking? Well, that's terrifying. If we're not actively reversing what's going on with a non-thinking brain, we're ending up as unhealthy as we would if we just didn't care about our diabetes at all and just kept doing what we were doing with eating and drinking all the things that hurt, you know, our kidneys, our liver, whatever it may be. So, you know, I it just taking that physical health and wellness now and shifting it into the mind and our thinking. What do you think of that comparison, Steve?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, that's great. It's you know, it's exercise for the mind. There is a lack of critical thinking in this world, I'll tell you that right now. I mean, it's just, you know, even in the day-to-day business world, people just don't think, you know, don't use common sense either.
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah, and that's and and I I would argue, you know, I saw a phrase recently, and I've been a big believer of this. C.S. Lewis was um the devil isn't out to destroy you, the devil is out to distract you. Right? And that's really the devil wants guys that are distracted and don't have time to think. Think about, you know, think about that for a second, Obi. That's what the devil really wants. Well, you don't have time to think about that. Just go with your gut. You know, go with your knee knee-jerk reaction and and let's move on. Or now it's let AI figure it out for you and what yeah, again, and who's who is creating the prompts for AI to take you down a certain path?
SPEAKER_01That's exactly right.
SPEAKER_02And and and you're you, you know, most of you would think, well, it's thinking, obviously, these are thinking people they're creating our artificial intelligence. Yeah, but are they are they thinking people insofar as right and wrong, good and evil, morality? You know, what does it mean to serve your neighbor versus be narcissistic? Are these the prompts that are going into AI? I don't know. Are these the thought processes? Or is AI right now, what I see about it, Obi, highly transactional and task-oriented? Well, shoot, that you just described most men on the call this morning. Let's get this over. I got stuff to do, right? So, yeah, thinking goes beyond the the transactional and the task-oriented, Obi, and it takes us into a different realm of our being that either we might be afraid to touch, we don't have the time to touch, uh, or we're overwhelmed by what it means to actually touch our thinking.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. And so this is what we're gonna do, but that's what we're doing here. We're actually emboldening in ourselves.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Look at what Gunner just put in the chat. He just did, like, Gunnar, jump in. It's better to remain silent at the risk of being thought a fool than to talk and remove all doubt.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you just think that like if I open up my mouth about a topic that I'm not so familiar with because I'm trying to include myself in the conversation, you know, it just it just can make yourself feel that much less about what you're talking about and who you are inside. You know, when you get the backlash from someone because you said something foolish or idiotic, and uh you're like, well, wait, where did you get that information from? You're like totally off left field here. And you know, it's kind of a an odd feeling to have. It's all one of those old China, it's Chinese uh proverbs, you know, that says it's like just be quiet and you know, but you know, that just teaches people to not talk because of fear of retribution and and and you know being considered a fool.
SPEAKER_02So we're gonna talk today. Two two key things that you bring up, Gunnar. Number one, a critical thinker is extremely humble. And we're gonna talk about humility being a key aspect of being a critical thinker, because becoming a critical thinker doesn't mean you walk into the room and you believe you're the smartest person there. A critical thinker means uh walking into a room and having the ability to create the best relationships through communication. So very humble, very open, but uh gunner, I would also say very courageous, very bold, and very confident. Uh, because uh a critical thinker is probably not going to be the first to speak, but is going to listen, ask good questions, and then respond. And you know, how many of us walk into a room and we recognize the guy uh or gal or the person that wants to be thought of as the smartest person and they just don't shut up, you know?
SPEAKER_05Uh what was that movie with uh Matt Damon in it? Where and his Goodwill Hunting? Goodwill hunting, and he's in the bar, and this one guy is trying to pull all these quotes and stuff and knowledge from the books to make himself look better, and then Matt Damon comes in and just obliterates him with true facts and and quotes and whatnot, just because he's pulling them from a book. He's like, you know, that's that's reading the room, you know.
SPEAKER_02So, what's the purpose of being a critical thinker and and and growing in our intelligence? We're gonna find out it there's it's twofold, really, just to narrow it down, Obi, I know Nobi's get like, we haven't even done the events yet. Uh, but this is great. It's really twofold to have a sound mind in Christ in a broken world. That's number one. Number two is in order that I might create stronger relationships with others, especially those that don't agree with me or I don't agree with them. So it a sound mind in Christ and growing better relationships with other people. That's gonna be uh the goal at the end of the day with critical thinking. Does the Bible, does God's word, does Jesus Christ actually want you to be a critical thinking man? And the answer is yes. There you go.
SPEAKER_06There we go. So we are going to hear words like metacognition, critical thinking, mental agility.
SPEAKER_02Um and recognize that Jesus was the best at all of those things. Jesus was the greatest metacognator that ever existed. He thought about his own thinking every day. He was the greatest critical thinker. You know, he processed through how to think through things critically, how to ask good questions. And then he was the most mentally agile human being that ever walked the planet. He was constantly, you know, people coming at him, Romans, Jews, you know, non-believers that are coming at him from Greeks, you know, all these different places, Obi, and a lot of them trying to trick him. And his mental agility to be able to respond on the spot, not just because he's the son of God, yes, but also because he was the greatest, most agile mental thinker as a human being.
SPEAKER_06And uh I don't want to just gloss over the word that you just dropped like nothing. He was the greatest metacognator. I want to be known as a great so so again that we're answering questions like why is the critical thinking an absolute necessity for authentic manhood in the 21st century?
SPEAKER_02Um, well, first you can go, you can go through this world on your own with your own thinking, not processing it, or you can go with it with the through it with the mind of Christ. Uh, and and that's that's the big point of this entire series is this world's challenging. The 21st century is challenging and it's dark. And and I love that imagery of the maze, Obi. And if if you're not going through it with the mind of Christ, you're walking through it on your own. And are you going to get through that maze that this world is today? And the the prominent answer is probably not. You're probably going to get lost.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Lost in the hustle and bustle. Yeah. First Corinthians 2 14 to 16 says the person without the spirit does not accept the things that come from the spirit of God, but considers them foolishness and cannot understand them because they are discerned only through the spirit. The person with the spirit makes judgment about all things, but such a person is not subject to merely human judgments. For who has known the mind of the Lord so as to instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.
SPEAKER_02You know, and there's some key words in there. Look at this foolishness, discernment, uh, making judgments about all things. The man that's in Christ and is beginning to grow and having the mind of Christ can make sound judgments about all kinds of things. Not just the spiritual things or not just the churchy things that take place on Sunday, but all kinds of things that include marriage, parenting, work, you know, how to do things ethically in the world. Why do we disagree with the way that that might be going on out there in the world? And why would we rather see it done this way? But it's not because we're telling Jesus what to do, but we're learning and growing from his intellect to have the mind of Christ to do it, Obi.
SPEAKER_06Are you saying that Christ is in the center and it goes out towards all these other things?
SPEAKER_02Andy, and leading us into making judgments about all these things. Here's another thing. When Jesus says, be in the world but not of it, to his disciples in John chapter 17, in the great upper room, you know, uh sermon that he gives them filled with love, and he's about to go out to the, you know, Garden of Gethsemane, be arrested, uh uh die on the cross, rise from the dead, ascend to heaven and rule over all things, he says, be in the world but not of it. He doesn't say, Don't be, don't be in the world. He doesn't tell them, hey, remove yourself from the world. He's telling them, if if you have me and you're filled with the Holy Spirit, you will be able to make judgments about all things in the world, but they're not going to be judgments of the world. They're going to be judgments that actually affect the world in a brand new way. And that's the kind of thinking, and that's the kind of men we want to be, is those that can be in the world, make Christ-like judgments about all things, and have a positive impact instead of letting the world just wash over us, OB. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06So, what's the big deal? Why critical thinking? Um, well, the critical problem we have is that everyone thinks.
SPEAKER_02He doesn't know that everybody, everybody thinks. I know, I know that might be a shock to you, and we might not believe it. We might look at that person and go, God, that idiot never had a thought in his mind. But the reality is everybody thinks.
SPEAKER_06Hey. Descartes said, I think, therefore I am.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_06That's high school for you. I remember that. It is our nature to do so. God created us to be thinking beings.
unknownYes.
SPEAKER_06But much of our thinking left to itself is biased, distorted, partial, uninformed, or downright prejudice.
SPEAKER_02So stop real quick. We we, the guys on this call, have a critical problem. This is us. It's not just the people out in the world that we we we believe in our minds don't think. But the first thing that we have to do, and Gunner, this is where the humility begins. I have to recognize this about myself, Gunner. Yes, I think it's in our nature to do so. God created me to be a thinking being, Gunner, but much of my thinking left on its own is going to be biased, distorted, partial, uninformed, or downright prejudice because we're sinful, broken human beings. So that's where we begin. We begin at the fall in the Garden of Eden, Genesis chapter 3, Obi, that all of us are struggling with right and wrong and good and evil. We no longer understand it on our own anymore without the mind of Christ. That's the base level where we're all at, Gunner. So that's the opening humility.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Uh yet the quality of our life and that of what we create, make, build, and share with others depends precisely on the quality of our thinking.
SPEAKER_02Uh look at that real quick. The quality of our life now depends on the quality of our thinking. Did you know that? Not how much I make, not how big my house is, not what car I have, not if we're keeping up with the Joneses, not if I have, you know, the beautiful wife or the great son, you know, but look at it now. The quality of life depends on the quality of our thinking. That's a that's a pretty big statement, Obi.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Shoddy thinking is costly personally, relationally, and financially. And therefore, it is costly regarding our quality of life.
SPEAKER_02Man, that's a big statement right there. Look at shoddy thinking is costly personally, relationally, financially, and to your quality of life. So why are we why are we doing this academic deep dive uh, you know, into critical thinking, Obi? Well, look at the kind of lives that are running around out there without it. And this isn't just about us having a better quality of life, but it's us growing in this ability to actually impact others that are having this lesser quality of life. And maybe, maybe learn this not just for ourselves, Obi, but maybe to help someone else.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Um, James 3:13 through 17 brings us to uh come to terms with two kinds of thinking. Um, and it says, Who is wise and understanding among you? Let them show it by their good life, by deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. Hey, there's that word again, Andy.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_06But if you harbor bitter envy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast about it or deny the truth. Such wisdom does not come down from heaven, but it is earthly, unspiritually, unspiritual, and demonic. For where you have envy and selfish ambition, there you will find disorder and every evil practice.
SPEAKER_02What powerful words right now in the political season that we're in, regardless of what side you find yourself on, but the propaganda machine that is rolling over us in every aspect of social media, right? And what we find then when there's envy and selfish ambition, because broken, sinful human beings are in our government and leading us, that's just reality, Obi. But what we find then is disorder in every evil practice. So our job then is not to think the same way, but have a different thinking that comes down from heaven, the wisdom of Christ, and in humility, maybe make a different impact.
SPEAKER_06Here we go. For where you have envy and selfish envy and selfish ambition, there you find a sore and evil practice. But the wisdom that comes from heaven is first of all pure, then peace-loving, considerate, submissive, full of mercy, and good fruit, impartial and sincere.
SPEAKER_02So you know everybody goes to Galatians chapter five. Write that down, guys, if you've never gone there. But a lot of people go to Galatians chapter five, and in Galatians chapter five, you get the fruits of the flesh compared right immediately then after with the fruits of the spirit, Obi. You know that? You know, here's the fruits of the flesh that bring destruction. Here's the fruits of the spirit, kindness, goodness, uh, love, mercy, grace, and all that. Here's the fruits of critical thinking and having the mind of Christ. Here it is, right here. These are the fruits of wisdom that comes from God, comes down from heaven. These are the fruits, Obi, of being a critical thinker with the mind of Christ. Pure, peace loving, considerate. Are you kidding me? I'm not supposed to be considerate, I'm supposed to obliterate that other idiot that doesn't think the way I do. Submissive, full of mercy and good fruit, impartial? Well, whoa, whoa, whoa. Wait a minute, you forget that I'm aligned to this side. I'm not impartial. Well, God wants you to be impartial. Why? We said this last week, Obi, we're going to bring it up all throughout this series. Where does Jesus constantly stand while he's on earth? He stands in the middle between Rome and Israel. He stands between Pilate and the Jewish Sanhedrin. Jesus is always impartial and standing in the middle because he comes from a different kingdom with a different way of thinking. So he stands in the middle of the partiality, right? He stands in the center of it all and speaks to everyone. And because of that, then he is sincere in what he thinks. Yeah, but this is a great list. Here it is. Galatians 5. This is kind of the Galatians 5 of what are the fruits of critical thinking and having the mind of Christ. Here they are.
SPEAKER_06Um 18 continues peacemakers who sow in peace reap a harvest of righteousness.
SPEAKER_02You know why? Because if if if we sow in peace and if we have that mind of Christ and we have those fruits of critical thinking in Christ, guess what we're gonna gain with another human being? We're gonna gain trust, we're gonna gain ongoing conversation, and we're gonna gain the opportunity to share Christ with them at some point instead of pointing a finger at them and telling them they're wrong. Yeah. Now, which one do we want? Do we want the strength and the empowerment? Do we want the pride to be able to look at another human being and point at them and say they're wrong? Yes, unfortunately, in our broken humanity, that's exactly what we want. Yeah. But in having the mind of Christ, what as critical thinkers, what we want to get to is the opportunity to share Jesus Christ with them in any conversation about any matter. But boy, that takes the fruits of critical thinking in Christ, Obi.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. So we had a critical problem. So we have a critical solution. Amen.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Excellence in thought, therefore, must be intentional intentionally and systematically cultivated, practiced, and lived out with others.
SPEAKER_02This is huge. Excellence in thought. Write that down today. Put it in your phone. Dear God, help me to grow in my excellence in thought. That's what a great. I just I'm praying over that every day, Obi. You know, I'm sharing my heart about certain things with you guys that I want you to grow in, not just me, but I want y'all to grow in it so that you can share it with others.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. And I gotta tell you. Yeah, go ahead, Mark.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, let Mark. Oh no, no, I was just saying it just, you know, it reminds me of Charlie Kirk, right? When you start asking questions and start to have his critical thinking. Um, and the challenge is, of course, you have other people having critical thinking that that is worldly and not not of God. And so that's where the clash comes in. And we've been seeing this, this, this ideology, uh, this culture, this godless culture that, you know, I'm smart, and if you're not this way worldly, then you're, you know, everything bad, right? You're you're judgmental, you're racist, you're bigots, you're all these bad things when you start talking about Christ. So that's a big change. Challenge for I think it's fun to talk to all you guys about critical thinkers. We can talk about different things and we all really get deep in the spirits. And I think it's great because we are in the Holy Spirit. But the challenge is talking to someone who's not quite there yet. You know, how do you start to where you begin?
SPEAKER_02No, I get so excited. Oh, because Marco, you just gave a plug for why to come back next week. So uh we're using critical thinking also in the outline of this series, just so you know. So we started with last week the big question is always why? Why critical thinking? We jumped into that. What are we doing this week? Well, we're doing the big what. What is critical thinking? Well, Marco, come back next Friday. We're doing the how. So now, how do you do this with other human beings in the world that don't think what you think or the way that you think? And I'm gonna dive into four key aspects with Obi. Uh, we're gonna dive into four key aspects. Again, kind of big words, but we're gonna dive into authority, identity, existentialism, and epistemology and how critical thinking works with those four key areas of life that everyone is thinking about, even though they don't know they're thinking about it, and how we can have a critical thinking conversation with somebody to help them understand, you know why we're having a problem right now? In those four key areas of life, you're coming from a very different background than I am. Let's start with why we're coming from different backgrounds. Can we talk about that first? And then you have a conversation about those backgrounds. So come back, Marco, next Friday. We're gonna talk about how critical thinking processes through kind of four main key areas of our life on this planet. And we're gonna do the how. So we did the why, we're doing the what, and next week is the how. So, even in the outline of the series, guys, we didn't bring that up because we just kind of wanted to do it, but we're doing critical thinking as we process through the series, Obi. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Well, we're gonna continue. Critical thinking is that mode of thinking about any subject, content, or problem in which the thinker works to intentionally improve the quality of his thinking by skillfully taking charge of the structures inherent in thinking and imposing intellectual standards upon them.
SPEAKER_02This is so huge, again, about any about what? About any subject. So not that we're just becoming critical thinkers about our faith in Jesus Christ and what does it mean believe in God, who's a Trinity and His Son came, died on the cross, rose from the dead, saved us from our sins, Holy Spirit indwelling us, but about any subject matter having the mind of Christ. Any subject matter, but then here's the thing, and especially as Christians, I'm gonna challenge us as men that we don't do that the world has called us out on. We do not impose intellectual standards on our thinking, oftentimes as Christians. We impose, like maybe biblical, you know, well, this is from the Bible, or this is the doctrines that we believe in. But we're not imposing intellectual standards, and the world calls us on that oftentimes. The number one thing that the world does, Obi, is goes, Well, you Christians are hypocrites. That's the number one thing that comes at me having coffee with somebody, Marco, at Starbucks, and we're getting into a deeper conversation about Christianity versus a non-Christian making their way through the world. And the one thing that I get as a pastor is, well, you Christians are hypocrites. Now, the immediate knee-jerk response without any actual intellectual standards is what I've heard from other Christians is no, we're not. But do you know how I answered that question? With intellectual standards based on my thinking, my immediate response was, well, of course I'm a hypocrite. I'm a broken, sinful human being. And do you know what that intellectual standard does with that other individual and it's happened time and time again? It stops them in their tracks and they go, Who are you? I have never heard anybody admit that they're a hypocrite. But OE, that's an example of an intellectual standard on our thinking when we're dealing with somebody else and they call us out. The knee, the knee-jerk reaction is, no, no, no, man, I'm not a hypocrite. I got Jesus. But the intellectual standard of the reality of our faith that, well, of course I'm a hypocrite. Of course I say one thing and do another. Ask my wife, ask my son, do what I say, not what I do. Of course, that's me. You know, Marco, that, but that's an intellectual standard now that we're asking men to put on their thinking. And it begins with that humility that Gunnar and I were talking about of, hey, you know what? In any conversation, you need to have the intellectual standard and be prepared to say, well, of course I'm a broken, sinful human being.
SPEAKER_04Nope. Because they think they think we're perfect. Like, oh, you're a Christian, so so you're righteous. That means you have to be perfect. And that's their belief system. That's why they look at us that way as hypocrites and and and all these bad things is because we're we're just like them. We're sinful, you know, but we're seeking and having a relationship with Jesus Christ. And there's a that's where the problem comes.
SPEAKER_02I'll take it one step for I'll take it one step further, Marco. I think they think we believe we're we're perfect. I think they think we believe that because we have Christ, we don't have to confess that we're hypocrites.
SPEAKER_04That's true. That's true.
SPEAKER_03You know, so I think there's yeah, go ahead. I think there's a there's a really good follow-up to of course we're hypocrites, is you know, asking the question, do you not set goals for yourself to be better than you once were? I've simply handed over the reins to say, what is the goal? I'm no longer determining that goal.
SPEAKER_02Got it. Yeah. But now, yeah, it is, but Jeff, you takes it takes time when I've done it. And you have to just get them to understand and trust you that you recognize that you're not perfect, that you don't think you're thinking's perfect, and that you are a person who can actually in humility confess your brokenness.
SPEAKER_03That goes a long way. Yeah, that time part of it is a struggle because if you just if you just lead off with that, then it's gonna come off as false humility, humility. And so that's that's where I I think it it's gotta be, it's gotta be really tough trying to do that at Starbucks when you haven't had time to develop that relationship to understand that no, I am a sincere person. I use a lot of sarcasm. I love to diffuse situations with humor, but at the same time, I yes, I'm a sincere person. And so that's uh that that that's probably a good course in itself of like a we need to do like a boot camp of on the spot conversations.
SPEAKER_02So we're gonna again, Marco, Jeff, I love that the advertisement, I love the commercials. That's next Friday. And I'm gonna delve into, I'm gonna delve into a little bit. So so you're saying my Starbucks conversations and what I'm interested in. And I'm interested in actually getting to know the person in front of me instead of winning an argument or getting them to confess four statements to know that now they're saved. That's not what I'm interested in. I'm interested in the human being who is sitting in front of me, getting to know them, hopefully that I'm getting to know me. And do you know what my goal is? That when I ask them if they want to meet again in two weeks, they say what? Oh my gosh, yes, this was amazing.
SPEAKER_05Can I can I say something real quick? You know, that you're talking about the advertisement for next week, but what it is for with Marco and and Jeff saying these types of things that follow on with this exact topic that we're talking about today, it just shows that it's true. Yeah, there's a lot of truth in that because it's sparking true responses of things that we're gonna be talking about in the future. They don't know that, they haven't seen the script. And here they are talking about things, bringing up the flow of what's gonna be said and how we can educate ourselves into being critical thinkers.
SPEAKER_02So uh goodness gracious, you guys are on this morning. Who needs a beer in seven? Who needs a beer at 7 p.m. to get this stuff popping at 7 a.m. in your track? So, Gunnar, what you have just said, and you brought up the key word that the church does. And instead of teaching critical thinking and and and intellectual excellence in Christ, having the mind of Christ, do you know what we teach in the church? We teach evangelism through a script, and you have to go through this script with somebody to get them to this point. And if you don't, you failed. Now that's what we teach in church a lot. Here's our evangelism script. Here's how you walk a non-believer through it, here's the goal that you want. Instead of actually a critical thinker who has the mind of Christ, who looks at somebody that disagrees with them and says, Why do you call me good? So when a rich young man comes to Jesus and he goes, Good teacher, what do I have to do to gain eternal life? Jesus didn't go into the four-point evangelism script that the church does. Jesus turned around and asked him a critical thinking question, Why do you call me good? Because he wanted more conversation with this human being in front of him, so that he could see the reality of what good means, because good, uh uh only God is good. And what Jesus wanted to get the rich young ruler to see is you're looking at God. How cool is that? You're having a conversation with God. Isn't that cool?
SPEAKER_06But nothing rush, yeah. Go ahead. No, and I think that that that really actually transforms the dynamic of the interaction that you have with somebody where now they're no longer. I think the problem happens when people people don't like to be seen as a project, right? They don't they don't want to be seen as a project. So I had somebody ask me, hey, well, how do I do this? How do I how do I successfully, you know, what do I say to get them, you know, and and and I just said, hey, dude, just start simple, man. Just talk to them, talk to them and get to know them, ask them questions that get you to know them.
SPEAKER_02People don't like to be seen like as a is as a pet project, you know, for the kingdom of Jesus, you know, care about them as an individual person before your agenda, uh, you know, as a you know, Christian who's supposed to share Christ with them. Yeah, because that's not what Jesus did. Jesus cared about him as his creature, his creation.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_02He loved them as his artwork. And those questions why he did what he did.
SPEAKER_06And the questions that he asked them were deep, thought-out questions that revealed that that allowed them to pause and think and reveal things about themselves. He's it started with that relationship with that thinking, you know, making them think, making them, you know, what is it? Why do you call me good? Well, you know, I hadn't really thought about that, Jesus.
SPEAKER_02It wasn't based on performing the law, you know. So, you know, and and and when we treat people like projects and they recognize it, what they feel is I'm smarter than you, and I have something you don't have that you need, you're stupid, and you're in need, and you need what I give you. Now, what I would say is, by the way, try treating your wife like a project, because we do, guys, we do, we treat them that way at times because we're broken, sinful men. But try treating your wife that way and see how that relationship goes. And then ask yourself this question why would any other human being out there want to be treated that way if your wife doesn't? But hey, this is where we're headed. So this is why this is getting into OBS, it's a little academic, it's a little deeper, but it has great purpose, practicality, and it's pragmatic for everyday life in living with other human beings. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_06Cool. So I'll continue about um talking about the critical, a critical solution.
SPEAKER_02If these guys would stop talking about next Friday, maybe we could get through today.
SPEAKER_06This is great.
SPEAKER_02I love it. This is awesome.
SPEAKER_06This is critical thinking is a mode, is that mode of thinking about any subject, content, or problem in which the thinker works to intentionally improve the quality of his thinking by skillfully taking care of the structures inherent in thinking and imposing intellectual standards upon them. Okay, talk about that. So Proverbs 14. Um you know, he it's talking about seeking in excellence in thought. Um, the mocker seeks wisdom and finds none. But knowledge comes easily to the discerning. Stay away from a fool, for you will not find knowledge on their lips. The wisdom of the prudent is to give thought to their ways.
SPEAKER_02But the now you mean now our thinking is connected to our actions?
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Uh oh. Uh-oh. But the folly of fools is deception. The simple believe anything, but the prudent give thought to their steps. The simple inherit folly, but the prudent are crowned with knowledge.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so this is, you know, book of Proverbs, probably coming from Solomon, about wisdom that he's passing down to the next generation. And for him, it's all about seeking excellence and thought that God has given him. Because if you don't remember, when God says uh to Solomon, I'll give you whatever you want to rule and reign over your kingdom, what is what does Solomon ask for? Does he ask for the greatest army? Does he ask for the most money? No, he asks for what? Wisdom. Give me wisdom to govern your people wisely.
SPEAKER_06Yep. He he thought he he has to be a well-cultivated critical thinker. So, what is a well-cultivated critical thinker? Well, uh cultive a well-cultivated critical thinker raises vital questions to problems, formulating them clearly and precisely.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and this is what's going on in a political season like this is very little of what I hear from anyone anywhere is clear and precise. It's very nebulous, ambiguous. You know, you know, it's it's aimed at another person instead of at a subject. So this is what we want to be able to do is we want to be able to communicate our thoughts clearly and precisely to somebody else and then understand theirs in the same way.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Um gathers and assesses relevant information, using abstract ideas to interpret it effectively. Comes to well-reasoned conclusions and solutions, testing them against relevant criteria and standards. Oh boy. Yeah. Thinks opened.
SPEAKER_02Not not just do what I say because I said so. Which I do all the time, by the way.
SPEAKER_06Uh thinks open-mindedly within alternative systems of thought.
SPEAKER_02Uh-oh, uh-oh. What? You mean I gotta be open-minded and think through alternative systems of thought? Yes. Doesn't mean you agree with them or you believe in them, but you've got to think through them.
SPEAKER_04You mean we can't just say free, free Palestine to get their attention? No.
SPEAKER_02I mean, anything that's based on a slogan is problematic, Marco, because it's propaganda-oriented instead of critical thinking oriented. Yeah, I that was a great example.
SPEAKER_06So recognizing and assessing as need be their assumptions, implications, and practical consequences, and communicates effectively with others in figuring out solutions to complex problems.
SPEAKER_02So, again, the at the end of the day, critical thinking is actually aimed at doing life with other people well. Did you hear that? Right? It's not just becoming the smartest person in the room, it's aimed at doing life well with others.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, and Andy, and this is this is a big problem that I that that you see with people that doom scroll, right? And get their information from TikTok, just scrolling, um, get getting fed algorithms, is that you don't have that that that part where you're sitting with them together, eating bread together, and trying to figure out, communicating with them to figure out the solutions to the complex problems, not just talking.
SPEAKER_02Right. So, and and also what depth of thinking are you getting in 15 seconds? I mean, do I even have to ask that question? There is no depth of thinking in something that passes by you in 15 seconds. And why is it created that way? Why are the most effective Instagrams 15 seconds? Because the purpose of it is to wash over you without thinking. Yeah, you're supposed to just take it for what it is, create negative dopamine in your brain, and walk away less critical thinking than you were before you saw it. That's what it's created for, guys. And we can get into a deeper conversation about it, but if anything's created for a 15-second hit on you, it's created to leave you unthinking for sure. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Well, um, you know, we were talking about being open-minded. Does the Bible talk about us being open-minded? Yes. This is out of Acts 17, 13. Now, the Berean Jews were of more noble character than those in Thessalonic Thessalonica, for they received the message with great eagerness and examined the scriptures every day to see what Paul said was true.
SPEAKER_02Well, look at that. So they didn't agree with Paul, they were hearing what he was saying, they didn't agree with it, but they started to listen to him and examine the scriptures to see could this guy be on the right track? That's critical thinking.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. As a result, many of them believed, as did also a number of prominent Greek women and many Greek men. But when the Jews in Thessalonica learned that Paul was preaching the word of God at Berea, some of them went there too, agitating the crowds and stirring them up.
SPEAKER_02Non-critical thinking, right? Knee-jerk reaction. And what did they do? This is very interesting with what's going on globally in the world today, Ada. Yes. So rage baiters, you know, protesters uh that are confiscating maybe a legitimate protest over a legitimate issue, but they see it as the opportunity now to go agitate and stir up even more so that people don't think about the original issue, you know, that was actually going on and creating some decent conversation. So you get a really great example here scripturally, Obi, of critical thinking Jews that are listening to this new preaching about Jesus. They go back to the scriptures, they're examining it and testing it versus the ones that come in and they just stir up trouble in order to get people to not think. Great example. I that has no relevance to anything going on in our world today, right, Obi? I mean, goodness gracious, we're still doing it.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_06So um, what's the big deal with a well-cultivated critical thinker? Well, uh, well-cultivated critical thinker understands that critical thinking is a serious endeavor for the mature thinker. Uh-oh.
SPEAKER_02Because now we're now we're saying critical thinkers are mature men, uh, mature people. Uh-oh. Uh-oh, Gunnar, we've added maturity to humility. This is getting serious.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Um, because it is self-directed, self-disciplined, self-monitored, and self-corrective thinking. Oh, um, it presupposes assent to rigorous standards of excellence as well as mindful command of their use.
SPEAKER_02About what? About anything.
SPEAKER_06It seeks to effectively communicate and problem solve with ever-developing abilities as well as a commitment to overcome our negative egocentrism and sociocentrism.
SPEAKER_02Wow. So that's a big one for our world today. Because number one, everybody on this call is a narcissist, whether you knew it or not. There you go. Critical thinking and being able to humbly admit, Gunner, that I'm a broken, sinful human being means I'm also a narcissist. I'm egocentric. I want everything to be about me, but Christ is setting me free from that and actually making me other-centered, other-oriented, and caring about other people. Right? So we have to recognize at the beginning that our thought process is in its brokenness all about me and what I want. Uh, so now we're gonna break free from that in Christ's know and actually see critical thinking as a way to actually engage and develop life with other people.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Pretty huge, Obi. Um, Hebrews 5, 11 through 14 says, We have much to say about this, but it is hard to make it clear to you because you no longer try to understand. In fact, though by this time you ought to be teachers, you need someone to teach you the elementary truth of God's word all over again. You need milk, not solid food. Anyone who lives on milk, being still an infant, is not acquainted with a teaching about righteousness. But solid food is for the mature who by constant use have trained themselves to distinguish good from evil.
SPEAKER_02Look at that last one, for verse 14. But solid food, critical, what we're talking about as brothers in Christ. Why are we on a subject matter like critical thinking? Because it's solid food, it's not milk, right? But solid food is for the mature, who by constant use have trained themselves to distinguish good from evil. So that is a great biblical example, Obi, of what is critical thinking? How do we define it? It is solid food for the mature who constantly use it and train themselves to discern good from evil about everything. So, really cool.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Well, let's take a quick uh trip through time.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, a little history, a little history. Past few minutes here, we're gonna get to the stages of critical thinking for you guys to think about this week and what stage am I at? Uh, so we'll get to there, Obi, and then we'll call it for next Friday.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Critical thinking is a rich concept that has developed over the past 2,500 years. The Greek philosopher Socrates pioneered the tradition 2,500 years ago through the Socratic method, a style of probing with disciplined questioning that challenges unexamined. Examined assumptions and test the logic of claims. Earlier pre-Socratic philosophers also applied critical reflection to nature and thought.
SPEAKER_02And by the way, so did Jesus. So pretty cool. Yep.
SPEAKER_06The term critical thinking has its roots in the mid-late 20th century. The specific phrase critical thinking was popularized and frequently credited as being coined by the American philosopher and educator, John Dewey, in his 1910 book, How We Think, or referred to it as reflective thought or a scientific attitude of mind.
SPEAKER_02There you go. So metacognition. There we go. But we're going to use Dr. Richard Paul, uh, who really was the pre-eminent professor on this through the 70s and the 80s. Unfortunately, he's passed away now, but his research is still the prominent research used, especially in Western thought about critical thinking, Obi.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Dr. Richard Paul says it is intellectual discipline process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, andor evaluating information gathered from or generated by observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication as a guide to healthy belief and action.
SPEAKER_02And here's what I love critical thinking is now connected to what the MLC promotes all the time, whole life health and wellness. So now critical thinking brings us to healthy belief and action. So it's actually a part of whole life health and wellness to process this particular conversation, Obi, that we're going through right now. It's making us healthier thinkers.
SPEAKER_06It is in this in its exemplary form, it is based on universal intellectual values that transcend subject matter divisions: clarity, accuracy, precision, consistency, relevance, sound evidence, good reasons, depth, breadth, and fairness.
SPEAKER_02And now here's with these things if we can agree on these things when we're starting a conversation with somebody, that we want to have these attitudes and characteristics, Obi, we can start talking about things that we don't agree on because the first thing we want to know is why what do you mean by that? Why do you call me good? What do you mean? I was having coffee with another guy at Starbucks and he wanted to talk about prayer. And my what do you think my first question is? Well, what do you mean by prayer? Well, you would think as a Christian, you're like, well, why'd you ask that dumb question? Well, guess what? Maybe we had different understandings of what prayer is. You know, so it can be about anything. Let's clarify what we're talking about with each other first before we get all emotionally heated, uh, thinking we agree on the definition of the term when we don't. And then maybe we'll find out, wow, we're speaking about extremely different things. Let's start there. And why is that important to you with that definition? And why is it important to me with this definition?
SPEAKER_04Andy, that's a that's a good point, Andy. Because I got like my sister who lives in DC, her and her husband a little more on the you know liberal side, but uh, she will send me information about, and that's fine, but she'll send me information about, you know, oh, something about something, you know, white national, um, white Christian nationalism, right? And so I'm thinking, okay, well, what does that mean to you? Because that's a good question. Let's be clear. That might mean something to you, and I define that differently. So you you're right, you have to get clarity on some definitions and what they mean about certain things so you can meet meet in between. Otherwise, you keep clashing it because you think it means something else, they think it means something else, it's it's it's not good.
SPEAKER_02And and both sides' assumption, Marco, is that you're talking about the same thing when you could be talking about widely different things.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But the assumption from both sides is I know what I'm talking about, so you must be talking about what I think this is. And that's oftentimes not the case.
SPEAKER_06Peter would call that being sober-minded, a sober mind. Um, therefore, with minds that are alert and fully sober, set your hope on the grace to be brought to you when Jesus Christ is revealed at his coming. As obedient children, do not conform to the evil desires you had when you lived in ignorance. But just as he who called you is holy, so be holy in all you do. For it is written, be holy, because I am holy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and this this sober-minded, you know, we unfortunately in our society today, we hear the word sober and we immediately go to alcohol and drugs. But what Peter is talking about is the things that cloud the mind in thought, which is exactly what the devil wants, because Peter uses this phrase sober-minded over and over again. And he uses it in particular in regard to our old man and our old way of thinking, that we are not sober-minded, but we're clouded. You know, it's distorted, perverted, colluded thinking. And then he also uses it when he's talking about the devil crouching around and crawling, crawling around like a lion in your mind to distract you, pervert your thoughts. So sober-mindedness is about clarity of thought in Christ, right? Holiness is about pureness. So when he's talking about being sober-minded, this is not like about addiction to alcohol and drugs. This is about addiction to false intellectual thought processes and thinking. So he wants us to be sober-minded. So critical thinking is a way, a tool of being sober-minded, Obi. How much farther can we get? Can we get one more? We'll get one more and then we'll stop. We'll do the stages of critical thinking next week. That'll be good.
SPEAKER_06Um, critical thinking can be seen as having two key components. One, a set of information and belief generating and processing skills. And about skills. We've got to have skills to be a critical thinker. Two, the habit based on intellectual commitment of using those skills to guide our actions and behavior.
SPEAKER_02So skills and habits. You got to have the skills, but then you got to use them regularly. You got to practice them.
SPEAKER_06It is thus to be contrasted with one, the mere acquisition and retention of information alone, because it involves a particular way in which information is sought and treated.
SPEAKER_02So this isn't data dump, this isn't information purge, which is what we get right now from when we turn to AI to do our thinking for us. You may gain a lot of information, but you still haven't processed through that information in the way that you're seeking to treat it.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_06To the mere possession of a set of skills, because it involves the continual use of those skills and the mere use of those skills as an exercise without acceptance of their consequential results.
SPEAKER_02So we've got to accept the consequences of our critical thought in dealing with other people, not just ourselves. Pretty cool. One last scripture. Uh no, that's okay. We can do it next week. Yeah, we're right on time. So yeah, really excited. I hope you guys are pumped about coming back next week because so many guys were already talking about the how. So we've done the why, the what today, Obi. Next week, we're really going to dive into the how. So I think it'll be really, really uh great conversation. Yeah, you want to close us out with a prayer, brother?
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Um, Lord, give us a sober mind. Wow, allow us to be people that walk in humility, not with a swagger. Um really seeing people and in the Imago Day, people that are made in your image, um, especially those that are lost, give us a a heart and a passion to be able to sit with them and break bread and actually get to know them. And um allow us to use the the mind that you've given us to actually break down walls, break down barriers, so that um the gospel of Jesus Christ might be spread, might be proclaimed across the the globe. Allow us just to be people as always, uh it's my prayer that you allow us to be people who don't just hear podcasts or hear books or read your word, but who are transformed by it and daily, daily lay down their pride for the sake of their weaker brother. We love you, and we thank you for everyone that was here. Continue stirring our affection towards you, and it's in the name of your son Jesus Christ that we ask our listenings, amen.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for joining and listening. We hope that you were truly blessed. Now you can join the live call every Friday morning at 7 a.m. Central Standard Time, and please bring a friend. And to learn more about the MLC, visit our website at the MLC.life. That's the MLC. Have a great day.