The Men's Leadership Community
THE MEN'S LEADERSHIP COMMUNITY
- For men seeking personal growth and heroic leadership at home and work
- For Men who are beat up, broken down & burned out from doing life alone.
Join a Brotherhood where Good Men become Heroic Leaders....at home, at work & in the world.
You can join the call live every Friday morning via Zoom @ 7:00am Central
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
The Men's Leadership Community
The Godly Thinking Man, Part 3: The 6 Stages of Critical Thinking
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Are you a thinking man, or a reactive one? In Part 3 of The Godly Thinking Man series, Andy and Obie get practical about the “how” of Christian critical thinking: not just what it is, but how to actually grow in it and use it.
The centerpiece is the six stages of critical thinking, from the unreflective thinker who jumps to knee-jerk conclusions, to the challenged, beginning, practicing, and advanced thinker, all the way to the master thinker who can understand others well enough to develop them. The guys challenge every man listening to honestly ask: where am I right now? (And they admit most of us are at different stages in different areas of life; stronger at work, weaker at home, and completely reactive when the week gets hard.)
Recorded the week of a divisive election, this conversation hits a nerve. The men talk openly about waking up “mad, hurt, and upset,” and then realizing the real war isn’t the ballot box, it’s getting people to Jesus. You’ll hear why your motivation changes everything (critical thinking can be used for selfish, prejudicial ends and still “work”), why we so often think we’re experts in fields we know nothing about, and the crucial difference between blind faith and trusting faith.
Along the way: Martin Luther on rightly discerning law and gospel, Socrates on the unexamined life, the danger of wielding the gospel “unthinkingly” and harming people with Jesus, and a closing challenge from James and Proverbs — be quick to listen, slow to speak, slow to anger.
Scripture anchors this episode: 2 Timothy 4, 1 Corinthians 2, James 3, Romans 12, Psalm 32, Psalm 14, Romans 3, Colossians 1, and James 1. If you’re a man who wants to stop reacting and start thinking with the mind of Christ, this one’s for you.
The goal: moving from transactional, propaganda-driven arguments to relational, trust-building dialogue. Because nobody cares how much you know until they know how much you care.
🎧 Join the live call every Friday at 7 a.m. Central. Bring a friend.
🌐 themlc.life
Part 3 of 8 — Critical Thinking Series. (Part 4 goes deeper into authority, identity, existentialism, and epistemology.)
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
Men welcome to the most important podcast that you'll hear in a long time. It's the Men's Leadership Community Podcast, and it starts now.
SPEAKER_01Hey, let's get let's get going. Um just some quick review. Quick review, kind of talking about navigating the reality of our current culture and how with the mind of Christ now we're able to actually navigate through the 21st century to authentic manhood in the in the 21st century. Uh and and we are going through this because you know we we have to understand why critical thinking is a necessity now in our current time, right? That we need to have be able to have the mind of Christ. Yeah, go ahead. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05You can navigate this culture all on your own, which you're gonna see right here in 2 Timothy 4, or you can navigate it with the mind of Christ. And that's the crux of this series, Obi.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. For the time is coming and indeed has come when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears, they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions and will turn away from listening to the truth and wandering off into myths.
SPEAKER_05There is the absolute biblical definition of the opposite of critical thinking right there in 2 Timothy chapter 4, guys. Yeah, so take a screenshot of it, remember it. But if you want the opposite definition of critical thinking from a scriptural point of view, this is it.
SPEAKER_01Just now let's hop into show over you. Yeah. Yep, let's uh head over to 1 Corinthians and see what it says. The person without the spirit does not accept the things that come from the spirit of God, but considers them foolishness and cannot understand them because they are discerned only through the spirit. The person with the spirit makes judgments about all things, but such a person is not subject to merely human judgments, for who has known the mind of the Lord so as to instruct him. Still, but we have the mind of Christ. That's the key.
SPEAKER_05So without the mind of Christ or with the mind of Christ, that's really what boils down to Christian critical thinking, Obi.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, kind of we kind of talked about the our big question what is critical thinking, and how are we defining it? Well, Dr. Richard Paul, uh philosopher, professor, and author, kind of gave uh the definition that we kind of thought fit.
SPEAKER_05He and his wife, so it's called the Paul Elder definition or the Paul Elder scheme. It's the one that our Western culture has been working with since the late 70s.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It is the intellectual discipline process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and reevaluating information gathered from or generated by observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication as a guide to healthy belief, communication, and action.
SPEAKER_05And that's the key, Obi. Critical thinking leading us to healthy belief, healthy communication, and healthy action.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05How often do we think that critical thinking has something to do with our whole life health and wellness? And this is why it's such a big deal for me, in the way that it ties into the overarching, you know, mission of the MLC, which is to advance whole life wellness in a broken world. Well, Christian critical thinking is a way to have healthy belief, communication, and action because it's healthy thinking.
SPEAKER_01Yep. In his exemplary form, it is based on universal intellectual values that transcend subject matter divisions: clarity, accuracy, precision, consistency, relevance, sound evidence, good reason, depth, breadth, and fairness.
SPEAKER_05Now I want to stop right there, Obi. I know we're on a uh, you know, we're on a rewind and just going over things again, but I want you guys to take those words in red, if you just saw, just saw them, or if you can't see them, that Obi just shared clarity, accuracy, precision, consistency, relevance, sound evidence, good reasons, depth, breadth, and fairness. And I want you to apply that to the main conversations that have happened in our world since Tuesday. And are you seeing those things at work in what you're hearing, what you're watching, and the way that people are discussing things? And I would say for the large majority, as I was watching this week, with this definition in mind, there's very little of that going on in the public sphere. That's just my that's my observation, right? Generated by observation, experience, and reflection. Okay. There's a whole lot of propaganda, there's a whole lot of personal preference, there's a whole lot of prejudicial thinking that that believes it's right and everyone else is wrong, but I've not seen a whole lot of clarity, accuracy, precision, consistency, relevance, sound evidence, good reasons, depth, breadth, and fairness going on. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01There's that word, Andy.
SPEAKER_05I know that's a that's a rough one. Uh which usually is is we gotta hold that one up as a mirror to ourselves, and we'll do a little bit of that this morning, too.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Um, critical thinking can be seen as having two key components set up information and belief generating and processing skills. So we're gonna let skills today. Yep. The habit based on intellectual commitment of using those skills to guide our actions and behavior. Whoa, tied to the habits, healthy habits in our thinking, Obi. It is thus to be contrasted with one, the mere acquisition and retention of information alone, because it involves a particular way in which information is sought and treated. Um, the mere possession of a set of skills because it involves the continual use of those skills. Hey, it doesn't you don't sit on them like a bike and then you never for you know, you just sit them on the show.
SPEAKER_05You have to see and and for all the guys out there that have seen Taken with Liam Neeson, when he's on the phone and he says, I have a particular set of skills, he then goes out and utilizes those skills.
SPEAKER_01He he really does.
SPEAKER_05He really does. Um, the throw our guy movie in there for Friday morning, JB. That might be that might be a brand new video. These men have a particular set of skills.
SPEAKER_01That is a good one. The mere use set of those skills as an exercise without acceptance of their consequential results.
SPEAKER_05Oh, you mean we have to accept the consequences of our thinking, our belief, our actions, and our communication? Uh-oh, OB, now we're talking about mature men, not immature men. Now the premature men blame everybody else, but mature men hate they believe that they have to accept and deal with the consequences in their own lives.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, so James, you know, uh talks about our our two kinds of thinking, right? And us coming to terms with um, who is wise and understanding among you? Let them show it by their good life, by deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. But if you harbor bitter envy and selfish ambition within your hearts, do not boast about it or deny the truth. Such wisdom does not come down from heaven, but it is earthly, unspiritual, demonic. For where you have envy and selfish ambition, there you will find disorder in every evil practice. But the wisdom that comes from heaven is first of all pure, then peace-loving, considerate, submissive, full of mercy and good fruit, impartial and sincere. Peacemakers who sow in peace reap a harvest of righteousness.
SPEAKER_05You know, and Obi, we talked about last time. If you want the fruits of Christian critical thinking that comes from Christ and having the mind of Christ, here it is. But the other thing that's really cool, Obi, is James chapter three, we don't immediately go to, but when we read Romans 12, right? We look, we we love to go to that passage over and over again. No, do not conform to the patterns of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. James 3 actually splits out and further defines the difference between thinking in the patterns of the world or thinking with a transformed mind in Christ, right? And that you get that perfectly laid out. You get Romans 12, 1 and 2 perfectly laid out in James chapter 3 in greater definition and greater detail.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, so the big question what does the three-foot view look like in your life right now? Where is there a desperate need for critical thinking?
SPEAKER_05And this is the big start this morning. Where we're critical thinking, Christian critical thinking, having the mind of Christ, what does that look like at from the three-foot view in your life right now? Where is there a desperate need, right? Because our need for Christ is desperate. So, where is there a desperate need for the mind of Christ to be a critical thinker in your life right now? And Obi, the the big thing about this, we're going to show you the stages of critical thinking. And I want you guys to chime in uh after you see them. There's six of them. There's six stages. I want you to be open, honest, and vulnerable, guys. And I want you to jump in on where you believe you are right now. At what stage are you in critical thinking? Because this will give you the opportunity now to say, wow, I've got some moves to make. Or if you think you're a master thinker, which is the sixth stage, I've got some people that I'm supposed to be pouring this into. So pretty big stuff here when we think about the stages of critical thinking. This is supposed to be self-reflective, Obi.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, one of the things that we saw right away when we first, I think was when we first started the series, we had somebody, I think it was Terry, David Terry, that you know, said, Hey, you know, this is really, this is really convicting to me. And as I'm looking, I I I feel like I've been there.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, because Dave has the tendency, like we all do in different ways, but Dave has a tendency to be a keyboard assassin in his social media use and in his desire through. Yeah, yeah, to be to be somebody out there fighting for Christ. So, Dave, I appreciate you being open, honest, and vulnerable, allowing me to to just point that out. But it was it was your critical thinking that said, I know this about myself, right, Dave? Well, he was there. Maybe we've scared him away. All right. Go ahead, Oak. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03No, I'm here. I'm I'm sorry. I was on I was on mute. No, absolutely. You know, you talk about since Tuesday. I was mad, I was hurt, I was upset, and next morning I woke up and realized, okay, we've got a a war to fight, and the war is getting people to Christ, not getting people to the ballot box. And yeah, I'm opposed to some stuff, but that doesn't matter. What matters is people standing before Jesus someday and him saying, Well done, good and faithful servant. Nothing else matters as much.
SPEAKER_05Well, and that the people that you are opposed to have an opportunity, if we do it well, to hear a different point of view than the one that they are living by, and they might actually hear about Jesus in a way that maybe they've never heard about him before.
SPEAKER_03So and and and vice versa. And maybe both of us can go share the kingdom a little bit better. And does that mean I'm gonna be perfect? Nope. Nope. But but it means I'm gonna be open and honest and vulnerable with people saying, Here's what I believe. But what's more important is that what I believe aligns with what I believe in Jesus. And if it doesn't, then I gotta honestly do a gut check and say, okay, what am I saying and what am I doing?
SPEAKER_05And remember, at the end of the day, when Jesus is hanging on the cross for the sins of the world, including yours and mine, he says, Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they do. And he is asking for forgiveness for the very people that are murdering him. Uh, so here's a man with critical thinking that has a perspective on what his purpose is and why he's been sent. And he's unflinching in it, and he does it with grace, mercy, and love. And yet he's uncompromising about who he is and why he's there. This is very difficult for us. We're incapable of it, Obi, because only Christ can pull that off. But he is alive now in our thinking. So I want you guys to really think about what stage are you at? Obi, you and I'll share where we're at. Uh, but let's generate a little conversation on where you think you're at at three feet uh in your life right now with critical thinking in Christ.
SPEAKER_01Well, so let's start with the unreflective thinker, right? Um, the unreflective thinker is unaware of significant problems in their thinking. They regularly jump to conclusions and solutions via knee-jerk reactions based on personal preference, individual bias, and oftentimes powerful prejudices. All right. We got the challenge thinker. I become there, by the way. The challenge thinker becomes aware of problems in their thinking. They begin to take a closer look at their thinking and dare to ask, why do I think that?
SPEAKER_05Now, at the baseline, for anybody that believes they're in the unreflective thinker camp, thank you for being open, honest, and vulnerable. But there is hope. This series actually has already moved you to the challenge thinker because you're here thinking about your thinking.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. And then we have the beginning thinker tries to improve, but without regular practice, they know they need to seek guidance to create a habit of utilizing new and undeveloped cognitive skills.
SPEAKER_05And right here, Obi, I'm going to say something dangerous. This is the church go over on Sunday morning that says, I want to be anonymous, I want to go in, I want to be fed, and I want to get out and go back home. You may have made it through the unreflective thinker, be careful. You may have made it to being a challenge thinker, but you're sitting comfortably at the beginning thinker who right now, right, is wanting to show up, hear something good, but is not seeking the guidance to create a habit of utilizing new and undeveloped cognitive skills. So the average Sunday morning churchgoer is in a repetitive washing machine cycle of unreflective, challenged, and beginning thinker and back again. Let's see, let's see how many guys click off now.
SPEAKER_01We got the practicing thinker recognizes the necessity of regular practice. So they intentionally dare to dive deeper into data, evidence, and understanding the experiences, others in order to peel the onion and get below the surface level opinions.
SPEAKER_05Now all of a sudden, critical thinking isn't just about you and your brain, critical thinking you opens you up to actually thinking about others and their thinking.
SPEAKER_01We got the advanced thinker is committed to consistently applying critical thinking to all aspects of life as well as an intellectual virtue.
SPEAKER_03Good.
SPEAKER_01As an intellectual virtue.
SPEAKER_05So now all of a sudden thinking is a virtue, and thinking well and in healthy ways is virtue us.
SPEAKER_01And then we have the master thinker. Um, it is a person in whom highly skilled and insightful thinking becomes second nature to them. They are able to clearly communicate not only their own thinking, but also clearly understand the thinking of others in order to develop others.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, now we've made the move to uh mentoring, discipleship, uh, wanting to take what we've learned, pour it into others because we now care about them in a new way. So those are the six stages, guys. Obviously, Jesus is the master thinker, the only one that ever walked the planet, but he is wanting to pour into us, Obi, to become master thinkers with the mind of Christ. And just get some thoughtfulness from some of you guys out there. Where do you think you are on that scale from unreflective all the way to master thinker? Anybody?
SPEAKER_03I I think in a way they're kind of like the love languages, the five loved languages, except for these, they're sort of sequential, whereas the love languages are are are a primary focus. But, you know, I I I wonder if a lot of us don't, you know, we we we sequence and we progress along this scale, these stages, but I'm betting we all have still a primary mode of the way we critically think. That and that's not necessarily a bad thing. You know, just because we haven't become Jesus means, well, we're not going to become Jesus, but we can become like him and more like him. But I'm betting we all have, you know, it was people are practicing and we can spend 80 years practicing, and that's that's not a bad thing either.
SPEAKER_05Well, are people practicing? That's the number one question, good point on the call. Are we practicing our thinking in Christ? Are we practicing having the mind of Christ? And I would say for a large percentage uh of Western culture, the answer is probably no. It's it's below, I'm I'm just using that below 23%. We know that already. So, but we want to move Dave to the MLC 100%. And by the way, all the guys that are on the call right now are actively working into right the practicing thinker in the advanced thinker realm. So we're already on the journey together, and that's the point. Why the people, when if somebody says, why do you do that on a Friday morning? So, well, I'm practicing my critical thinking in Christ, I'm working at it with other guys, whether it's this actual series or whether it's a, you know, in the new year, we're gonna hit a book of the Bible again, whether it's a book of the Bible series that we're going through, or whether it's the movie series. By the way, that's a great one, Obi. When we do the MLC at the movies, that is master thinking that Obi and I sit down picking the movies and going through them on how we're gonna discuss those as critical thinkers in Christ through media and through entertainment. You've got to be at the advanced and master thinking level just to present that content, guys. And then when you take it in with us and you're like, oh, that movie or that movie, or how are you able to tie that in? Oh, that's what I was thinking. Then you're brought into the advanced and master thinking level at the movies, you know, and then you and you want, yeah, go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, that that's the great part, right? That then you have somebody that says, Hey, I was watching this other movie the other day, or I started watching movies now, and and and I'm starting to see these things. I'm starting to look at these things differently, right? And that's what and this is what this is about changing the way we think so that we are now looking at the world through a different lens.
SPEAKER_05Yep.
SPEAKER_01Um, so that it's very encouraging when we see that.
SPEAKER_05Let me throw this in real quick with um Steve McNeese is another systematic guy, a systematic thinker, uh, just in in the way God put you together with your unique gifts and what you do for a living, Steve. But what do you think about this, these six stages, and where do you feel that you fall right now is one of our key leaders?
SPEAKER_02Well, well, it's interesting because as we as you were going through those two different slides, I realized that I think I'm in different places depending on where I'm at. You know, at work, I think I'm a little bit further along. At home, I'm in another area. And when I'm walking around, uh, you know, you know, like Tuesday, I'm in a certainly in a different area. Uh a lot of preference, you know, in that in that route. Unreflective thinking. Yeah, just unreal night Wednesday morning. Exactly. In fact, I I had to I had to put together an image, and I sent this one to Dave. I didn't send it anywhere else, but it was really part of my healing. You know, it was just a it was a split image of what I what I expected to see when I woke up and what I actually saw, which was God still in control, yeah, looking down over Texas. But um Yeah, I think I'm in different areas, which I don't know if that's good or not.
SPEAKER_05I I think I think that's reality. No, I think that's reality, and and I think that helps us also two things. Number one, I think that's reality. I don't think this is a static, uh, I'm at this level and I can't wait to get to this level. I think it's a growth mindset, and that's what you're expressing instead of the static, oh, I'm at stage four and I've been stuck here for a while and I can't wait to move forward. So, number one, it's a growth mindset, not a static. But number two, I think what it also helps us to realize, Steve, is we are still highly compartmentalized, fractured and splintered. And in certain areas, we're really great at our critical thinking. And in other areas, we're brought right back to being a two-year-old who pouts and screams because we're hungry or got poop, you know, one or the other, you know. So it kind of just shows even in our own minds with different aspects of our lives, uh, that we've got room to grow. And that's see, the advanced thinker isn't that you're actually applying it to every aspect of your life, but what you just did, Steve, is you did advanced thinking thought saying, Well, I'm not. Yep. Or I recognize it's at different levels in different places. And uh, this is the wholeness and the whole life, health, and wellness of Christ. He had one, you know, way of approaching everything. And, you know, he was the only holistic human thinker. There was not an aspect of his life where it was off or this, it was better over here. And I think that's the beauty of growing in the mind of Christ is that we might grow to consistently applying this to all aspects of our life, knowing that it's not always going to be great. But your recognition of it was awesome, Steve. And I think that I think that puts you in that advanced thinking realm.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I would say that it's a litmus test, really, on where that you are being transformed, that your mind is being transformed, because the the man that isn't uh constantly thinking and that doesn't have that critical thinking through the mind of Christ doesn't see that, doesn't see that he needs any of that. As a matter of fact, he probably just goes straight to one of these and says, you know, I'm pretty much almost to that master thinker in all aspects of my life, but somebody that's actually being transformed by the gospel of Jesus Christ in humility realizes that, you know, hi, there's there's I'm very compartmentalized.
SPEAKER_05Um so well awareness, recognition, ability to to then share it with others in clearance. Sync way like you just did, Steve. Uh that is what prevents you from going, well, I'm at this level and I'm comfortable with it. I don't, you know, I don't care. Uh so that's that already just the fact that you you shared that, Steve, is a desire to want to continue to grow and move forward. And that's what we want out of everybody is growing in the mind of Christ.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And not just because me and Andy think so, but because we actually pull this out of scripture. Um uh so James 1, 22 to 25 says, do not merely listen to the word and so deceive yourselves. Do what it says. You guys always hear me pray this because that is my biggest prayer that we're actually not just people who listen to God's word or read or listen to a podcast or read a couple of books and we're done and set. Um, we want to be actually people to actually do what it says. Um, anyone who listens to the word but does not do what it says is like someone who looks at his face in the mirror and after looking at himself goes away and immediately forgets what he looks like. But whoever looks intently to the perfect law that gives freedom and continues in it, not forgetting what they have heard, but doing it, they will be blessed in what they do.
SPEAKER_05And that is not only listening to and understanding what the mind of Christ is, but going out and living that out in every aspect of our lives, growing in it. So that's what we're really after. And here you can see in our world, uh, just this week, here's the leadership bomb for the week. Why is critical thinking and especially critical thinking in Christ so important in our world? Look at what Socrates and Richard Paul have to share about those that are unthinking.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Socrates said the unexamined life is not worth living. Oh, and then uh Dr. Richard Paul says, Critical thinkers realize that many unexamined lives together result in an uncritical, unjust, and dangerous world. Huh.
SPEAKER_05That's kind of poignant for the week that we're in. Wow. You mean this stuff might actually have real life pragmatic, practical things that we could learn from? Well, you know, this is a guy that said this back in the early 80s, by the way, Obi. Here we are once again.
SPEAKER_01Well, and let's see what they said actually in the 800s. No, I don't know.
SPEAKER_05This is from David. This rest from David. This is actually Psalm 32 and Psalm 51 are pulled out regularly as the uh confessional psalms of confessing sin, receiving forgiveness, and becoming transformed uh through God's forgiving mercy and grace. So look at what David says as he's uh gone through confession, received forgiveness, and has now moved back into the mind of Christ that he wants to live in moving forward.
SPEAKER_01I will instruct you and teach you in the way you should go. I will counsel you with my loving eye in you. Do not be like the horse or the mule, which have no understanding, but must but must be controlled by bit and brittle, or they will not come to you. Many are the woes of the wicked, but the Lord's unfailing love surrounds the one who trusts in him. And this is so huge.
SPEAKER_05God is saying, Don't be like the horse or the mule who have no understanding but must be controlled by bit and bridle. Uh that this is what happens to unthinking people. Uh, the world will put a bit and a bridle on you and will steer you where it wants you to go, which is to dangerous and unhealthy places, which is then where the many woes of the wicked are. So the examined life, though, goes, No, I am thinking through this. Uh, I'm not going to be put in that prison cell of being unthinking. And that's really kind of like where we get back to books like 1984 and Fahrenheit 451, Obi.
SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's let's answer the big question because we can sit here and talk about what critical thinking is.
SPEAKER_05Let's get into the how, baby.
SPEAKER_01But without finding the the how, right? Uh, how does how does critical thinking work? We won't know what key aspects of life to apply it to and how to apply it to that. So, what is our motivation, right? What's my motivation? Well, critical thinking varies according to the motivation underlying it. Uh, when grounded in selfish motives, it is often manifested in the skillful manipulation of ideas in service of one's own or one's group's vested interest.
SPEAKER_05So you're telling me that critical thinking can actually be used in an in a harmful, sinful, evil way? Yes, it can be.
SPEAKER_01As such, it is typically intellectually flawed, however pragmatically successful that it might be.
SPEAKER_05Oh man. So you mean this critical thinking can be prejudicial, self-motivated, flawed, and yet still be effective? And the answer is yes. We're watching that all around us right now, guys.
SPEAKER_01When grounded in fair-mindedness and intellectual integrity, it is typically of a higher order intellectually, though subject to the charge of idealism by those habituated to its selfish use.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so we're gonna have people that are come at us as we're growing in our critical thinking of Christ and say, Oh, well, that's just your idealism of your religion. And the answer is no. Uh, so we need to be able to respond to that also. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01The foolish heart, the foolish says in his heart, there is no God, they're corrupt, their deeds are vile, there's no one who does good. The Lord looks down from heaven on all mankind to see if there are any who understand, any who seek God, all have turned away, all have become corrupt. There is no one who does good, not even one. And I didn't see an asterisk there. No anybody's.
SPEAKER_05This is that mirror, Obi, where we gotta look to ourselves and say, what's our motivation in going through this and learning how to be better critical thinkers in Christ? Well, the reality is we first have to come to terms with the fact that we are some of those guys, right, that are going to use it for our own selfishness, our own prejudicial purposes, because Psalm 14 speaks the truth, and there is no asterisk, Obi.
SPEAKER_01I was hoping I kept hoping that there was I looked down there to see if my name was on there or my picture or anything like that. But Andy, how wicked, how wicked are our hearts that you started looking for many of that, you know, all have turned away, all have become corrupt. There's no one who's good. And I was like, Yeah, those guys, right? Those guys, yeah.
SPEAKER_05But that that's the week we just had. Oh, Psalm 14 is about those guys over there. No, Psalm 14 is about you sitting in the bathroom and looking in the mirror. That's right. As as as Nathan once said to King David, you're the man, you're that guy, bro.
SPEAKER_01Hi, dude. And if you want to take it all New Testament, Romans 3:23 through 24 says, For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and all are justified freely by his grace through the redemption, through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus. And there's that word again, all. But there's good news, there's good news.
SPEAKER_05So we're part of the all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. But now, as men and brothers in Christ talking about this on a Friday morning, guess what? We are the ones that have also been freely justified by his grace through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus. And we're not just talking about critical thinking, we're talking about having the mind of Christ and critical thinking being being a skill, a tool, and a habit that helps us to better do that.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's talk about this.
unknownCool.
SPEAKER_01How do we do that? Um, critical thinking of any kind is never universal in any individual. Everyone is subject to episodes of undisciplined or irrational, irrational thought.
SPEAKER_05Correct.
SPEAKER_01Its quality is therefore typically a matter of degree and dependent on, among other things, the quality and depth of experience in a given domain of thinking or with respect to a particular class of questions.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so there that that's a key one right there. And I think one of our Psalm 14 Romans 3 moments that we all have as men is we believe that we're experts sometimes in fields we know nothing about. So let's just let's just go ahead and admit that right now, okay. No one, but I know I'm right. I know I'm right. Yeah, go ahead. Oh, here's one of our experts right now, Jason. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_04Yep, that that's exactly right. So, what you're telling me is when I watch CNN or Fox News and they tell me what they tell me is might not be the truth.
SPEAKER_05Yes. That's what you're telling me. But I'm more so I'm saying we fall into that ourselves, Jay, and become experts in fields we have no business talking about.
SPEAKER_04I I am only expert in one field, and it's divorce.
SPEAKER_05No, no, no. Uh yeah, that's what it is. Well, you know what, you have an experience of brokenness that you can share with others because you don't want them to go there. So there's a lot about marriage and divorce that you have expertise in, unfortunately. But you know, being a business owner, an entrepreneur, uh pharmacy, uh, you know, I'm way out of my depth with you and your sister, my wife. Uh, when when I talk about, you know, or or I hear about, I don't talk about, I'm smarter than that, by the way. But when I hear about big pharma or evil pharma or whatever, you know what, Jason and Jennifer may have a different point of view on pharmacy than what's spewed out there for the public consumption, you know, and Jen does. So, you know, and Jen's a critical thinker when it comes to that, Jason, in that field. She'll share what she thinks is unfortunate about big pharma, but she'll also see why pharmacy is a positive in our world. And I listened to her then as an expert in that field versus a machismo guy who thinks he's an expert over everything and tell her what I think about pharmacy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And even she and I disagree on some of that, but yet can have but her explaining like the drug company side of it. You know, I just know what I pay for drugs. And so I I can be very stereotypical about that. But from her, from her point of view, I do look at those things a little bit differently because and and I think she carries a a side of her into those places that are are retail pharmacy friendly, you know, just because we've we've been able to to have those careers.
SPEAKER_05But just think of this, Jason, from the different perspective of pharmacy, uh, that that you and Jen engage. So there's pharmacy for education. You guys have been through that. There's pharmacy in the hospital uh that's used in practice, there's pharmacy for the broader public, right? Which could either be at the community level or at the global level. Uh, and then there's pharmacy that's aimed at specific and unique illnesses or, you know, disease stakes. And then there's how those drugs are used for prevention, post-op, uh, ongoing, you know, care for long-term disabilities or whatnot. So that right there, I am not an expert, but I've already been taught this. So when my wife tells a story of telling me not to give a five-point sermon to her ever again, goodness gracious, I know a lot more about pharmacy than I ever did, but I know enough not to talk about it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04You know, I do I do struggle with, I do struggle with that. You know, it it sometimes we're just meant to listen.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I've gotten better at it, but it's still difficult.
SPEAKER_05You know, and Obi Greg Baker put up a great example from Winston Churchill. What a great leader, what a powerful thinker, what a powerful communicator, Greg. Uh, but he insisted on overseeing and directing the surgeon for a dear friend's procedure and almost killed him. Well, think about that just as men who are not growing in their critical thinking to have the mind of Christ, Obi. What we can do with the good news of the gospel to people when we wield it unthinkingly. We can actually harm people with Jesus. That's true.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, and I see it, I see it played out again. There's my shameless jab at the prosperity gospel, played out with the prosperity gospel, people that are speaking uh with authority over something that they obviously do not understand because if they bother to read the scripture, they would find out that it implodes on itself very quickly.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and Luther, Luther said this. He said, the highest form of thinking, this is Martin Luther the reformer. He said the highest form of thinking is properly discerning God's law and God's gospel and what the person in front of you needs. Do they need to be slayed and killed by the law because they're in their sin and they're on the way of a dangerous path that leads to death? Or are they already dead inside and the law has crushed them and they need to be brought back to life through the gospel message of hope, mercy, and grace? But Luther said that's the highest form of critical thinking. And how many people even walk around discerning the law and gospel, even knowing these two words from God and what somebody in front of you might need to hear? Let's just start at that basic level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Wow.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, continuing to what we were talking about on developing critical thinking. I like this. Listen to this. No one is a critical thinker through and through, but only to such and such a degree with such and such inside and blind spots, subject to such and such tendencies towards self-delusion.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, but that's true. That's all of us. So critical thinking begins with recognizing this about ourselves, that God is going to bless us to grow in experience and expertise in certain areas of our life and being able to think through it and think about others and communicate it. And in other areas, we're going to need to be taught, we're going to need to be poured into, and we're going to be need to be able to say, Wow, this is a subject that I really struggle with. So you know what? Maybe I should shut up and listen. And that's where the self-delusion for me enters in. You mean I have to be quiet?
SPEAKER_01Well, Andy, you know, this is why so important to be for this is why discipleship is a perpetual thing, right? It never stops. Um it never, you don't graduate out of it, but this is continuing, and that's why it says developing a lifelong exercise.
SPEAKER_05This isn't an eight-week course series or whatever, and then by Christmas, you guys are all like little packages to your family and saying, Here's your gift. I'm blessing you with the the reality that I'm now a critical thinker in Jesus. Merry Christmas, everyone. No, this is the rest of our lives, guys. Yeah. I'm gonna try then though and see how it goes with Drenan and Sam. Here's your gift, by the way. I'm now a critical thinker in Christ. Merry Christmas. God's gift, God's gift for you. Straight from Andy Whaley. Oh my gosh. For this reason, but I think that there that's the that's the truth. But I think that, don't y'all?
SPEAKER_01Like at times. Sorry. Well, we're you we're gonna get you a big long bow, you know, that you can just put on yourself and then just walk in and say, Hey, listen, uh, here I am. Um for this reason, the development of critical thinking skills and dispositions is a lifelong endeavor.
SPEAKER_05Exercise in the mind from here on out.
SPEAKER_01Hey, Colossians 9 through 14 says, For this reason, since the day we heard about you, we have not stopped praying for you. We continually ask God to fill you with a knowledge of his will through all the wisdom and understanding that the Spirit gives, so that you may live a life worthy of the Lord and please him in every way, bearing fruit in every good work, growing in the knowledge of God, being strengthened with all power according to his glorious might, so that you may have great endurance and patience, and giving joyful thanks to the Father, who has qualified you to share in the inheritance of his holy people in the kingdom of light. For he has rescued us from the dominion of darkness and brought us into the kingdom of the Son, He loves, in whom we have redemption for the forgiveness in the forgiveness of sins.
SPEAKER_05So this is the ongoing, enduring, persevering critical thinking to have the mind of Christ from this point forward. Yeah, yeah, really beautiful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so what's the goal, right? Yeah, what are you doing? That's what we were talking about. What are we talking about? Um, you know, think, you know, the elements of critical thinking. We got a a nice little, and if you want to take a screenshot of this, we got a nice little uh slide talking about you know some of the things that the elements of critical thinking, um, being aware of our limitations, recognizing that our perception and memory are prone to errors. That's a hard one for some people, and starting with me, arguing with evidence and logic, using well-structured arguments that are supported by evidence and avoiding logical fallacies. Yeah, um, thinking about our thinking, examining our thought process, including emotions, assumptions, biases, and motives.
SPEAKER_05Yo, yeah, whatever exhibiting that that was that was a really good one for this week, by the way, gentlemen.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exhibiting intellectual humility, recognizing the limits of our knowledge, and being willing to change our minds with evidence. Oh, oh. Old dogs, new tricks. Uh uh.
SPEAKER_05Oh boy, okay.
SPEAKER_01Seeking seeking objectivity, striving for accuracy by considering diverse viewpoints and holding our beliefs loosely.
SPEAKER_05Now that sounds dangerous, but actually, what it's supposed to be doing is saying we don't even consider at times different viewpoints, Obi. We shut them down and don't listen to them, we don't process them. And then all of a sudden, here's the here's the danger about not holding our beliefs loosely, okay, and considering diverse viewpoints. There's a difference between trusting faith and blind faith.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And God wants trusting faith in him. That's a thinking faith, that's a feeling faith, that trusts in him and who he is can communicate that and share that. Blind faith is stupid. Blind faith is ignorant, blind faith is non-intellectual, non-emotional. Uh, and this is not what we're after when we're talking about being followers of Jesus Christ. We're talking about trusting faith, not blind faith.
SPEAKER_01You know, Andy, that's you know, that's something that I really had to wrestle with because I grew up uh with that being taught to me that that are you know, we we're supposed to have blind faith. Yeah, just believe, just believe. Why? Well, well, no, just believe. Just believe. And so it so it requires no effort on on discipleship, on on teaching of scriptures and understanding scriptures, what God, what they say about me, what they say about God. And it's lazy.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's funny in the Great Commission. The Great Commission is not lazy, it's not blind, blind faith. It says, as you're going, right, do this, make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, and teaching them all things that I've commanded you. So it's not blind faith, it's a a trusting faith that is filled uh with God's information for us in how to follow and trust in Him.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Big difference.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Moving on to maintaining healthy skepticism, questioning claims, considering alternative explanations, and proportioning our beliefs to the evidence.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, go ahead, Andy. Some of the best conversations I have at Starbucks with people are ones that are very skeptical of the Christian faith, right? But I enjoy those conversations because I maintain a healthy skepticism uh of you know, in my own thought process that, hey, they're they're excited, they're asking questions, they want to know, they're skeptical. You're not supposed to get angry at that, you're supposed to appreciate that they're thinking through and asking questions and be able to respond to people who have a healthy skepticism.
SPEAKER_01So that's pretty huge. Um, here's a here's a big one: having curiosity and open-mindedness, possessing a desire to yeah, possessing a desire to learn and understand by asking questions and seeking out information. And then last but not least, embracing nuance and uncertainty, avoiding black or white thinking and accept that knowledge is imperfect.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's a really good one. That you know, our knowledge is imperfect. It's may, you know, it's it's it's growing in Christ, but it's still battling the old man. Uh, and really that the opportunity of embracing nuance and uncertainty has to do with dealing with another human being sitting in front of you instead of uh an argument, a right or wrong, a proposition, a theory. You have another human being sitting in front of you. So we need to embrace the nuance and uncertainty of that person. They need to embrace ours. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um and we're talking here, like, you know, continuing or talking on what what the goal is. What is our what is our our end goal here?
SPEAKER_05This is really huge. Take it. This is another one to take a screenshot of. What are we moving from to uh and we'll start with this again next Friday because it's so huge, Obi, but go ahead.
SPEAKER_01To move from transactional, propositional, and oftentimes propaganda based divisive arguments. Over a heated prejudice perspective to a relational, to a to a relational discovery-based trust-building dialogue on the journey with another person. There we go. That is huge. Yeah. Nobody cares how much you know until they know how much you care. To seek to understand before seeking to be understood. Example to be able to communicate regarding four key areas of life today, including but not limited to authority, identity, existentialism, and epistemology.
SPEAKER_05And I we'll we'll start with these next Friday, that these actually are four areas that I believe that we need to be thinking about before we even make the move to politics, religion, sex, drugs, and rock and roll.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So these are huge. If you don't know and can't define with the person in front of you, uh what we mean by authority, identity, existentialism, and epistemology, you're already going to have a bad conversation about anything, not just about religion or politics, but about anything.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and you know, I I really do think, and Jeff said this, he he's the one that kind of said this the first time I heard it, uh, Jeff Presler. He's, you know, so many people are really worried so much about being right.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Over being righteous. And I think that's a big deal.
SPEAKER_05Righteous is building and repairing broken relationships.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_05You don't do that by beating somebody over the head with how stupid they are.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm gonna, I guess we'll end it with this, right, Andy?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, let's wrap it up here for this week.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. This is out of James, the three different scriptures out of James Proverbs, um, that says, My dear brothers, take note of this. Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry. You may need to put this on the mug, guys. Um, this this next this next couple of weeks. Uh Proverbs says, to answer before listening, that is folly and shame. And then last but not least, a gentle answer away rasp, but harsh words stir up anger.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so I'll bring it all the way back to JB at the very end and say, I've got a certain set of skills. Gentlemen, we need to have this certain set of skills, but then we need to go out and use them with people, okay?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh, I'm gonna pray for us and then we can, you're welcome to stay for the after party because we'd definitely love to hear what you have to say uh in regards to all of this. Lord, we thank you so much. Uh my prayer, my prayer is always that you allow us to be people that don't just attend a Zoom call and and and talk and and just talk to talk and and read uh read a few chapters uh out of a Christian book or out of the Bible or hear a sermon, but are actually people that are transformed by the the gospel of Jesus Christ, by the red letters, by uh what you want us to do through your word. And I just pray that you'll we allow your Holy Spirit in our lives to move us, to compel us to see people as more than a project, to see people as more than uh a tag or a label. They allow us to see that they're made in the image of God, people that need of a savior, just like we are. So I pray that it'll you give us opportunities to begin conversations with depth and they open our minds so that we can become critical thinkers with the mind of Christ. We love you, and I'm thankful for everyone that's here and everyone that's going to listen. And we ask all these things in the precious name of your son Jesus.
SPEAKER_00Amen. Thanks for joining and listening. We hope that you were truly blessed. Now you can join the live call every Friday morning at 7 a.m. Central Standard Time, and please bring a friend. And to learn more about the MLC, visit our website at the mlc.life. That's the MLC. Have a great day.