The Men's Leadership Community
THE MEN'S LEADERSHIP COMMUNITY
- For men seeking personal growth and heroic leadership at home and work
- For Men who are beat up, broken down & burned out from doing life alone.
Join a Brotherhood where Good Men become Heroic Leaders....at home, at work & in the world.
You can join the call live every Friday morning via Zoom @ 7:00am Central
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
The Men's Leadership Community
The Godly Thinking Man, Part 4: The Four Questions and the Seven Principles
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
How do you have a real conversation with someone who doesn’t want one? In Part 4 of The Godly Thinking Man series, Andy and Obie get intensely practical just in time for the Thanksgiving dinner table about how a man thinks and talks with the mind of Christ.
The core of this episode is a toolkit every man can use. First, the four questions underneath every hard conversation; authority, identity, existentialism, and epistemology, the things people are really arguing about long before they get to politics or religion. (Who’s actually the authority in your life? Where does your identity come from? Why are you here? And how do you know what you know?) Then the seven principles of critical thinking; fallibility, truth-seeking, clarity, burden of proof, charity, suspension of judgment, and resolution, reframed as a Christian’s guide to arguing well and loving better.
Along the way the guys get honest and funny: the power of “I don’t care” about winning an argument, the art of the Irish goodbye when things get heated, why your kid “is not a broken line of code” to be rewritten, and the difference between being right and being righteous. They tackle steel-manning instead of straw-manning your opponent, why “whatever happens in Vegas” is a lie, how social-media algorithms profit from your outrage, and why breaking bread with someone beats shouting from behind a keyboard.
Scripture anchors the whole thing: 2 Timothy 4, 1 Corinthians 2, Galatians 2:20, 2 Corinthians 5, Romans 1, James 1:19, and Proverbs plus the stories of Zacchaeus and the Pharisee in the temple, and a word on being an ambassador of reconciliation rather than the guy who has to fix everyone.
If you’re a man who’s tired of winning arguments and losing people, this one hands you the tools to do the opposite.
🎧 Join the live call every Friday at 7 a.m. Central. Bring a friend.
🌐 themlc.life
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
Men welcome to the most important podcast that you'll hear in a long time. It's the Men's Leadership Community Podcast, and it starts now.
SPEAKER_02Well, this series is one you I mean, you probably can't go back and listen to this series enough, guys. This is it. Obviously, some of the deepest content we've ever done. For some people, they may think it's super academic, but we're trying to present it to you that it's actually very practical to everyday life. Uh, for for for men to be godly thinking men is a very practical thing. But you can go back and listen to this series over and over again and pick up something uh that that you didn't necessarily get when it was live, or you listened to it the first time, go back again and again because actually, Obi, I've been practicing this now going on over 15 years, this this metacognition, critical thinking, and mental agility. So this is coming to fruition of now not just practicing my myself or practicing it just with you and mentoring one-on-one, Obi, and you practicing it with somebody, but now we're we've actually got it down and hopefully content that can go out into larger groups and actually make an impact. I I argued last time, and you guys tell me what you think about this today. This is the kind of content, Obi, that I actually should be taught before we ever teach apologetics or evangelism. But we skip it, we skip it and we go to hey, let's go get the work done, like we always do. Yeah, hey, let's go do it. And you're like, but why are we doing it? How do we think through how to do it? And this is kind of the groundwork academically, yes, but also practically that actually the church should be doing with all of its people before we engage in apologetics or evangelism. And and on that's a that's a dangerous statement. Yeah, go ahead, Jason.
SPEAKER_07And timing, you know, you said present it present it in a way that that means something to us. And I I wanted to say, I I mean, you guys blow it away with that. And it's a it's always amazing to me how how how much it fits into my life. It's like right now we've been going through this, and this is very important to me because you know, at this point in my dad's life, he kind of retired mentally. And and we, you know, we know how that's worked out, not well. So it it's a I have that nature about me of wanting to, I don't want to learn anymore. I don't want to do this, I don't want to do that. But we're going through this right now. And this week I was presented with probably in my entire 36-year career at the store, the biggest opportunity that has ever come my way. And I give God all the glory, but if I wasn't, if I wasn't listening to this stuff right now, I don't know that my head would be in a place that, hey, I can do this. You know what I mean? So I mean, it just I just want to share that just because it it's the the timing, not only the presentation, but the timing always amazes me. I know it shouldn't, but it does.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, nice. Thanks, Jay. Yeah, and it's practical, just you know, and I love your sharing it. It's practical. This kind of godly thinking is practical also as a business leader, you know. So as a father, as a parent, I'm going through it. It's timely for me, Jason, especially as a dad, empty nesting for the first time. And you guys know all the struggles that I'm going through, letting go of that and everything. And it's it's just been amazing for me to be a better father right now than I would have been without going through this series with you guys. So think about that. You know, it's it's awesome precursor to apologetics and evangelism. It's awesome, precursor to making a business decision. It's awesome to have this kind of conversation with other men. Oh, we to be thinking men to be better husbands and fathers.
SPEAKER_08And and what more relevant time than is right now? You know, we strategically made that right now because in in a world that is constantly bombarded by different entities that are trying to sway you just for the sake of engagement, because engagement for these social media companies equals money, right? They're making a lot of money. And so we need to be able to have that mind of Christ to be able to navigate um just the reality of it.
SPEAKER_02Up in our world this week. That was a guy, okay, just like any any one of us, could be any one of us, but that was a guy that was not doing metacognition, was not doing critical thinking, uh, had had lost his mental agility, one of the most brilliant men in the world. And look at what happens when we let our guard down and we're not thinking men. You know, there's a you know, there's a phrase that says, something else will do the thinking for you if you're not using your brain, guys. And the reality of that happened in the world this week, you know, and came to light. Like, and it it's it's not just affecting one individual's life, it's affecting our culture, it's affecting things globally on the stock market. It's crazy, you know. So if you're not gonna use your brain, something else gonna do the thinking for you, man.
SPEAKER_08And yeah, that ain't godly. No, that is not the godly. And we have a diagram on our uh one of our slides that we're playing right now that has you know what it looks like when we're on our own. And it's a a figure of of a of a man standing before a maze with no direction as to where to go. And then the the other frame that I really love is the same scenario, but there's a cross that that can be seen that is uh leading us through the maze. Leading us through the maze. And and so and and for Gunnar, I think Andy was talking about uh the NVIDIA, right? The CEO of NVIDIA who who really really messed up.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like just not this is one of the most brilliant men in the world, but he stopped critical thinking when it came to the most important stuff.
SPEAKER_08Yeah, yeah. And so put his company in jeopardy. So this is why it's so important for us to be able to take a step back, uh, to be able to look at things in a way that is Christ-like, um, and and so that we can make wise decisions. Yeah. Because, you know, I I believe it now that it, you know, as is a man, as a leader of my family, the the luxury of sinning and it only affecting me is something that is long gone.
SPEAKER_02No, that's not a reality. That whole whatever happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. We've talked about that lie. That's a lie. You know, when you step in poop walking the dog outside and you walk back into your house, the poop's on your shoe when you walk home. And when you walk in the house, the poop's still on there. So that whole lie of whatever happens in Vegas, uh, you know, stays in Vegas, OB, it's not true.
SPEAKER_08No, there's always collateral damage, always collateral damage damage.
SPEAKER_02Now, I like I like these two verses. So you look at the slide, had them side by side, navigate life on your own. That's this first set of verses, 2 Timothy 4, or navigate life with the mind of Christ. That'll be the second set of verses. Again, look at these verses in practicality of the way that we're thinking through our day in Christ. Like, look at what can happen when you're not thinking with the mind of Christ in 2 Timothy 4. This is what's going on in the 21st century right now.
SPEAKER_08Or the time is coming, and indeed has come when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itchy ear, itching ears, they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's just that's going on all around us, and it's actually wooing that right there is trying to woo all of us on this call into it today to want to hear what our itching ears want to hear. So that that is a a call of the sirens, if you guys know the Odyssey, right? That's a call of the sirens to here's the greatest thing you could ever have, only to crash against the rocks and die.
SPEAKER_08Mm-hmm. Uh, whereas in contrast, the mind of Christ, the person without the spirit, does not accept the things that come from the spirit of God, but considers them foolishness and cannot understand them because they are discerned only through the spirit. The person with the spirit makes judgments about all things, but such a person is not subject to merely human judgments, for who has known the mind of the Lord so as to instruct him? So who, Andy?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_08But we have the mind of Christ. We have the mind of Christ.
SPEAKER_02You know, and I love in verse 15, we we're gonna hit this every week. The person with the spirit makes judgments about what? Churchy stuff, Christian stuff? No, about all things. The person with the spirit is thinking through and making sound judgments about everything. And that's that's huge, Obi, for what we're talking about, especially with men with the mind of Christ.
SPEAKER_08Yeah, because we're no longer compartmentalized. Remember, we're running, we're we're doing away with that mindset. We remember we talked about the paradigm shift where we're, you know, uh separating um all of these aspects of our lives, but now Christ is in the center of our lives. And with that, we have the mind of Christ that outwardly manifests itself in the way we think about other things.
SPEAKER_02Now, here's the danger of this. Here, there's a dangerous side of this, guys. All of a sudden, if if we're filled with the Holy Spirit, we have the mind of Christ, and we start making godly thinking man judgments about things. Guess what? Some people are gonna start noticing and they're gonna start coming to you, and they're gonna start asking you for advice and for counsel. And God forbid that it's godly thinking men that people start going to to ask advice and counsel. What should I do with this in my marriage? What should I do with this with my kid? What should I do with this in my business? You know, what's going on in my community or whatever? And then all of a sudden, just that grassroots movement, Obi, of godly thinking men thinking in godly ways that other people notice and recognize and start coming to them and asking them about it. Yeah. That's the impact. And then all of a sudden, what's really cool about that, Obi, is we're not like sitting down with the script of how to mentor somebody, right? But now people are showing up and going, Hey, why did you do that that way? And you're in the moment of mentoring already, which is really awesome. So this is what's coming.
SPEAKER_08That's how society that's how there's shifts in society. That's how you transform uh villages, right? It starts with us. It starts with us. So, you know, what's the end goal here? You know, because we're we're not just talking just to talk and and doing little Zoom calls just to Andy and I can have, you know, a side a side hobby.
SPEAKER_02You know what's amazing about this? When you look at this graph, and Obi's gonna talk through them real fast, but if you can look at it on your screen, take a screenshot. You look at this, this is a this is a purely academic graph from from Dr. Richard Paul uh and his wife, Laura Elder. They created this of what is the goal of critical thinking? And look at this, Obi, and tell me what part of this is not actually scripturally based for godly thinking men. And and that's what's amazing about it is good thinking and godly thinking go hand in hand.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_08Yeah. We're modeling, we're modeling our thinking like Christ. He was the greatest thinker of all time, right? Our prime example. Uh so a couple of elements of critical thinking, being aware of our limitations. That's recognizing that our perception and memory are prone to errors, guys. Uh-oh.
SPEAKER_02So you mean it you mean critical thinking begins with confession and absolution?
SPEAKER_08Absolutely. Yes, it does. Um, arguing with evidence and logic, using well-structured arguments that are supported by evidence and avoiding logical fallacies.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, give unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and give unto God what is God's. Oh, you mean Jesus argued with evidence and logic? Absolutely. Okay.
SPEAKER_08Thinking about our thinking, examining our thought process, including emotions, assumptions, biases, and motivations.
SPEAKER_02And every morning he went out by himself and in solitude. He prayed to his father in heaven and asked for the gift of the Holy Spirit. Jesus thought about his thinking every morning, every single day.
SPEAKER_08Um, exhibiting intellectual humility, recognizing the limits of our knowledge, and being willing to change our minds with evidence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, now Jesus didn't have to change his mind, but he showed intellectual humility with others who are not at the capacity level that he was at. One of the greatest ones that I have, you know, you guys always remember who climbed up the sycamore tree? Do you remember that, Obi? Who was little Zacchaeus, right? The we little man. We Zacchaeus, right? So not only a wee little man, stature-wise, but he was struggling intellectually, climbs up the sycamore tree to see Jesus coming. And Jesus, with his intellectual humility, says, Zacchaeus, I have to have dinner at your house tonight so that we can talk. So he builds relationship with a man in order to share that intellectual humility. He exhibits that to him so he can get into his house and share with him the truth of the gospel message and how Zacchaeus is living his life inappropriately. Wait, see, he's radically transformed through that intellectual humility.
SPEAKER_08Well, you know, and you know what I what I'm positive that Jesus didn't do go in there and tell him Zacchaeus, you're a piece of crap. How dare you? You need to sell all your, you know, make things right. No, he he he got on his level with humility, talked to him, and the power of the gospel convicted his own heart. And he said, Whoa, hey, something's something's not aligning here.
SPEAKER_02Isn't that amazing that Jesus never walked into a room and said, You're a little piece of crap. I mean, that's that's thank God for that. Now, he did walk into some rooms and and say, Woe to you, Pharisees, which is pretty bad, but uh yeah, yeah. You know, that's the other thing is Jesus was pretty straightforward about never calling your brother Raka, which is fool. You know, so when you're in conversation with your brother, never call him Raka, never call him fool, but deal with him like another human being. So that that intellectual humility that he had, even as godman, you know. But I struggle with having that, and I'm just a man man.
SPEAKER_08Seeking objectivity, striving for accuracy by considering diverse viewpoints and holding our beliefs loosely.
SPEAKER_02Now, this is gonna be one. So do you guys know what a straw man is? You set up a straw man, somebody else's argument, so you can simply knock them down and feel really good about yourself. And like I knocked down that argument, I'm so much smarter, I'm right, they're wrong. Look at the way I knocked them down. We're gonna talk about actually stealing your opponent, as in the word steal, you know, iron sharpens iron type stuff, Obi. But to steal your opponent means that you can argue their side of the argument better than they can. When was the last time that you sat down and you thought about, hey, I don't agree with this. I'm gonna take time to argue it better than the people that I don't agree with, so that I can understand where they're coming from and actually understand why my argument, my position holds better weight.
SPEAKER_08Takes too much effort, Andy.
SPEAKER_02So seeking objectivity, though, is all about that effort, that accuracy by considering that diverse viewpoint and actually learning how to argue that viewpoint and know it better than they know it themselves.
SPEAKER_08Yep. Pretty cool. Maintaining healthy skepticism, questioning claims, considering alternative explanations, and proportioning our beliefs to the evidence.
SPEAKER_02Hey, when we die, we're all gonna become angels. Isn't that great? Well, maybe that maybe we ought to question that, Obi. But did you know that 60%? I think no, it's up to 68%, I'm sorry, of uh American Christian women actually believe that when you die, you're gonna become an angel based on two television shows, not scripture. Yeah, do you think maybe maybe we should have some healthy skepticism even amongst ourselves about what we say about our faith and go, well, I'm not real sure that's right. Let's talk about that with each other for a minute. Let's reason with one another. I don't I don't think we're gonna become angels, and here's why. But that's a real example. I mean, everybody, hey, we're getting ready to watch It's a Wonderful Life, right? And the star of the show, you know, Clarence, dead human being waiting to get his angel's wings. I mean, it's in our popular society, right? Touched by an angel, highway to heaven. Yes, your wives have heard of these things, your grandmothers have watched these things. I always like into our belief system.
SPEAKER_08I always like to uh always like to example this one. Do you remember the shack?
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_08It was like a number one bestseller, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_08Uh and you know, when they're talking about God, you know, about Jesus, you know, he's not just the way, he's the best way. And people ate that up. I mean, like, you know, uh like a seven-layer burrito.
SPEAKER_02They swallowed that up and yeah, the other the other thigh side is like people are waiting for their three by five note card in the mailbox that God's gonna send them instead of asking to be baptized, like get the real guarantee of eternal life, yeah, right? God's work on your life of you know, that was the other thing is people are like, how come I didn't get a three by five note card? Does God not love me as much as the guy in the book? I'm like, he ain't sending you know three by five boat note card, but he's sending you the guarantee of eternal life in his son through the power of the Holy Spirit, water and word. Amen. Yeah, that thank you.
SPEAKER_08Oh that was a banger, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Steve McMeese, you're not, yeah, you're not, you're just not praying hard enough. That's another one, Steve, that that we should question with healthy skepticism. So you mean that my faith going well is based on my performance and not God's grace and mercy. I'm in trouble. Yeah, well, we we all are, yeah, yeah. Because we all got performance anxiety and performance issues, man. When it comes to holding up our end of the bargain with God, get ready, it ain't pretty. So yeah. Go ahead, Obi.
SPEAKER_08We better move forward. Moving on. Having curiosity and open-mindedness, possessing a desire to learn and understand by asking questions and seeking out information.
SPEAKER_02You know, Jay just hit on that. Like, you know, we we we have members in our families, Jay and I know his dad, you know, he shut down. He didn't want to learn anymore. And and and that has had a bad effect on his life in a lot of different ways. Jay's like, I don't want that. You know, I could easily fall into that, but I want to stay open-minded. I want to learn. And that's a passion that we can all lean into together, staying open-minded, having curiosity. What are we gonna learn with each other today?
SPEAKER_08Yeah. Uh, embracing nuance and uncertainty, avoiding black or white thinking, that accepting that knowledge is imperfect. And this is now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this is a big one, accepting that knowledge is imperfect. God's word is inerrant. You know what that means? God's word, it had we believe it has no errors in it. It comes from God, uh, written by men through the working of the Holy Spirit over centuries, over millennia, right? But the issue is the the men and women that are sharing that word with others are broken, sinful human beings. So we're always going to have to accept the fact that there's nuance in that, that there's brokenness in the sharing of God's word. God's word is perfect and pure. We are not, but we're the ones sharing it with each other. And we've got to recognize that and accept that. And the avoiding a black and white thinking, Obi, here's where critical thinking gets real hard. And John Briniger, he's chatting in. I love this. He's like, you know, most of our struggle with looking at other viewpoints is it's almost like requires active critical thinking. Thanks, John. That was awesome, little commercial. But here's here's the problem. We need to avoid black and white thinking because we are supposed to live in the gray. We're supposed to live in the tension. Because that's where Christ stands, and that's where Christ lives. We're supposed to stand in the tension of opposing viewpoints. When we get into black and white thinking, right? And we're getting into mutually exclusive things, then all of a sudden we don't even recognize, Odi, that we've chosen uh an extreme. Yeah. And now we're living on one extreme and pointing at another instead of living in the middle and dealing with human lives that are broken and messy.
SPEAKER_08Well, and let me just let me just add that the the social media algorithms love for you to be black or white. They love for you to get with your group and then spew vitral and hatred towards the other group. They love that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're echo get stay in your echo chamber. Don't don't listen to what somebody else might have to say. Only listen to what your own voice sounds like.
SPEAKER_08Well, guess what? I don't like my voice. So we keep talking about what's uh what's our end goal for this, right? Why are we doing this, Andy?
SPEAKER_02Uh, so you know, the the point of that graph that we just saw is is really aimed at this definition, Obi, that you and I have come up with for the MLC right here, is that to move from transactional, propositional, and oftentimes propaganda-based divisive arguments over a heated, prejudicial perspective. That's that black and white thinking, to now a more relational, discovery-based, trust-building dialogue on the journey with another human being. That's the goal of critical thinking, Obi, is to move from that theoretical to now the relational.
SPEAKER_08Yeah. Because nobody cares how much you know until they know how much you care. It's all built on relationships. To to seek and to understand before seeking to be understood requires effort to be able to communicate. Regarding four key areas of life today, including but not limited to authority, identity, existentialism. And here's this word that we talked about that we kind of gave a preview last week. Epistemology.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, you know, before you ever get to religion, politics, sex, drugs, rock and roll, power, wealth, whatever, these are four key basic aspects of being a human being that everybody thinks through, even though they don't know they're thinking through it. So we want to, we actually want to metacognate on authority, identity, existentialism, basically, what does it mean to exist? And epistemology, what does it mean to have knowledge and know where it comes from? We need to know that about ourselves first. What's my thoughts on authority? Right. Uh, you know, uh, do I do I have a high respect for the authority of God's word or a low respect for the authority of God's word? Do I believe that God's word has authority over my life? Or do I believe that I have authority over God's word to pick and choose which aspects of God's word to live out? Do I believe that I'm under the authority of a king who's reigning over all things? Or do I believe that I'm, you know, voting, you know, for a president uh, you know, in, you know, who's who's governing over all things but wants to hear what I have to say about how he should govern? Like, what's your true viewpoint of Jesus? Is he the authority of your life and is he king over all things? Or do you have a viewpoint that Jesus is a lot like Ronald Reagan and you voted him into office, so he's gonna bring about things in your life that you agree with? Got to be careful of those things. You know, um, Paul Harvey said, you know, that back in the day in the early 80s, any guy over 40, when he had a vision of Jesus in his mind, had a vision of Ronald Reagan. Like that was the confusion that can take place when we don't even understand authority in our own lives. Are you your own authority? Are you the end-all be all of authority? Or do you live under the authority of Christ? This is, you know, where does your identity come from? Does your identity come from being a self-made man and uh you've got this incredible career and you've made this amount of money and you drive this car and have this house and all that? Or does your identity come from Galatians 2.20? I've been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. Is that your identity? You know, and then and when you sit down with another human being in front of you, Obi, that we we should ask what they what do you mean by these things? What do you mean by authority? What do you mean by your identity? Where are you getting your identity from? Oh, well, the world tells me I can be whoever I want to be. Okay, that's where you're getting your identity from. You're getting it from the world and your own broken heart. How's that going? Annette Pride, how's that working out for you right now? You know, or existentialism, you know, where do we come from? Why am I here? What's my meaning and purpose? What's our what's our end game? Where are we headed? What what you know, epistemology, how do you know what you know and where does it come from? Like all these four things, Obi, make so much impact in a conversation with another human being to first understand that maybe you're not working from the same backgrounds with one another before you jump into abortion or or transgenderism, you know, or whatever the conversation of of today is, you know? Because maybe there's uh an issue that you guys could work out with one another before you get to those, you know, hot topic or hot button items. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_08Absolutely. It starts with relations, right? Relational. It starts breaking bread. That's why, you know, I'm always so impressed by that. And I I you can't convince me otherwise, but there's something really powerful about breaking bread together. There's a reason why, Andy, you know, you go and have coffee with somebody, I go and have Taco Bell with somebody. Uh, there's something powerful that happens when you're sitting in front of this and talking to somebody that's made in the image of God and interacting with him. Whereas instead of sitting behind the keyboard and spouting, you know, your venom.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, you're in a common moment, you're in a common moment of what we call common grace, where you maybe you can both agree that this moment is a gift.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Maybe you don't agree on a lot of stuff, but maybe you can agree it's a gift to be with each other in this moment. And breaking bread is awesome, Obi, coffee, whatever it may be, because now you're both engaging a common need that you don't actually provide for yourself, but that God provides. Beautiful. Beautiful.
SPEAKER_08Yeah, beautiful. Well, I've got some scriptures for you guys.
SPEAKER_02Um, and by the way, we're after a mature goal, Obi. Critical thinking asks asks for men to grow in their maturity, which I am struggling with in my own life at times, but critical thinking asks us to grow up into a mature thinking.
SPEAKER_08My dear brothers, take note of this. Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry. Wow.
SPEAKER_02There's three skills to practice right there.
SPEAKER_08Yeah. To answer before listening, that is folly and shame. That's not a proverb. But that's what we do.
SPEAKER_02I already know, I already know what you think. I haven't asked, but I know what you think, and here's why you're wrong. Is that not what we see in our world today? Yours is mutual dialogue? Yeah.
SPEAKER_08A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so some pretty good stuff here on just how to enter the conversation with another human being.
SPEAKER_08Well, check out this quote by Dr. Samuel Johnson. Whatever we hope to do with ease, we must first learn to do with diligence.
SPEAKER_02The goal, Obi, is that critical thinking becomes second nature to us. That, but what his point is, and here's a critical thinker before critical thinking had a name to it, is if you want critical thinking to be second nature to where you're just doing it naturally, you got to start though by practicing it diligently. You got to practice it over and over and over again in every aspect and area of life, every aspect or area of thinking. And you're gonna recognize number one, I'm not good at critical thinking over here, but I'm pretty good at critical thinking over here. Yeah, Andy.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, go ahead, Dave. I have I have I struggle when I get in a conversation with somebody about either either politics issues or religious issues with somebody, and they're they're not critical thinking, right? It's all emotion.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_06And I struggle with how to question it without you know enraging them more. Because when I when I do ask the questions sometimes that are a little bit deeper, they turn it into even more emotional. So how do you how do you work to get around that? Because like sometimes some people like I have some friends that you can have conversations with that are actual conversations about politics, and you may not agree, but you can they can actually articulate the side they don't believe in or the religious part that they struggle with, and that's fine. I I respect if you can articulate it, but when it's you know, orange man bad, and you know, he's he's this, that, or the other. And I'm like, everybody is, right? None of the if in all honesty, none of the politicians, and for that matter, none of us humans are perfect, though. There was there's been one perfect person in the history of the world, and that was Jesus Christ. Other than that, we're all full of sin. So let's stop with that part of it and let's let's move to the other part.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I got two things on that note, Obi, or anybody else chime in on how you handle that. Number one, I have learned to say to myself, especially in the past five years, I don't care. And what I mean by that is I go into a conversation, uh, a mutual dialogue with somebody else. I don't care about being right or winning an argument. I care about sitting with somebody and spending time with them. So I've learned how to say, I don't care. And it has even come out in conversation, like, why are you not getting upset about this? I'm like, well, I just I don't care. You know, I don't uh it's not emotional to me to care that point because my job isn't to be right, my job isn't to win an argument, my job is to proclaim Jesus Christ and Him crucified if the opportunity is available. And by the way, this is the second part then, Dave. The opportunity is not always available. The other side can shut down the opportunity to present Christ in a loving way based on their own emotions, their own desire to be right, their own desire to fight, whatever it may be. So I don't care in my own heart. I already know that I'm calm and I'm not gonna get emotional. I don't care about winning an argument, I don't care about being right, I care about spending time with other people. But I also know that somebody else might not be able to do that. And in scripture, it says, here, here's in your Bible in English, it says, when it when it's up to you to bring peace, bring peace. Well, that's written in Greek. And what we what we don't realize when we read scripture in English, Greek always also insinuated or assumed the opposite. So when you're reading Greek, oftentimes and it says something like, whenever it's up to you to bring peace, bring peace. The opposite side of that is when it's not up to you to bring peace, recognize you're the person that can't bring peace. Like I'm also okay, Dave, with walking away from a conversation. And the practical way that I do that with family and friends is I do an Irish goodbye. When somebody starts to get really upset, no, ask Jen. I do it, I do it all the time. When someone's like in good, you just say, hey, hold on, real quick, hold on. I can see you're getting excited. Hold on, I gotta go do this, so I'll be right back, and then don't go back.
SPEAKER_07Andy. Andy, that's Jay see. I've done this with Jay. Yeah, that's what I was gonna say.
SPEAKER_03Jay's witnessed this.
SPEAKER_07It it it is a it is it was profound for me to watch.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_07And not only did it did it say to me, man, I'm not acting right. I'm not acting right enough that my brother-in-law has to leave the room. That's pretty pitiful. And there were times that I didn't even recognize it, but your example of leaving the room, especially today, in in this journey that I've been on, especially today, was profound. And and every I'm not gonna say I don't still get carried away, but almost every conversation I have that gets carried away, I think of just that. I think of you leaving the room and and not inserting yourself in it. And then as far as what what we were talking about, you know, like politically or or even talking to somebody that it's it's not about politics, you know, that's where prayer comes in. And the only way, the only way I've ever seen somebody try to understand your side or or you you you or whatever it is, whether it's politics, religion, whatever, is to love them. If you love them and and they know that you care about them and you really want the best for them, nine times out of ten, the they'll listen. But you've got to be able to listen too. And that's something that you've taught me.
SPEAKER_02Jay, yeah, and Jay, you've also witnessed this, though. There's some people that I love and care about, but I'm not the right one to bring them to the moment of healing or recognizing who Jesus is. And and I think that's a hard one on men because we want to be the guy. We want to we want to fix things, and it's hard to remember in a conversation you're not there to fix somebody. You're there to be another human being. And there are just there are certain people in this world that I have spent time with that I recognize my personality, the way that I talk about things, the the the scratchiness of my voice, which comes without bourbon and cigar smoking. This is just the way I sound, like irritates the hell out of them. And you're just not the guy then. And that's that's what I meant, Dave, by I don't care. Like, I don't care if I'm not the guy either. But that's the mature humility that comes over time regularly that Jason has seen, even in our conversations with each other, but he's seen with our family of like I'm okay with not being the guy.
SPEAKER_07But hey Andy, but it in that it in that not or being okay, not being the guy, you really are being the guy. Yeah, you know what I'm saying? Yeah, with your example, whatever it is, even with your your quiet nothing, no words, you really are being yeah.
SPEAKER_05I I was gonna say sometimes that's the best witness is not saying anything, you know, and that's a that's a hard thing to do. And yeah, I think you hit it right on the head because we are, you know, as men, we want to fix it, you know, especially with our family, you know. You just you're you know, I think of myself as the fix it dad. They can come to me with a problem and I'm gonna fix it for them. But sometimes you just can't do that.
SPEAKER_02But you're what you're and and I already know you know this, Steve, but your kid is not a broken line of code, right? See, and that's what when we get to the maturity of thought that that my kid's not a broken line of code that I need to rewrite and all of a sudden it'll be better. But a human being that's do it dealing with a brand new season of life and emotions they've never experienced, and all of a sudden they're scared and or they're exhilarated, or uh, you know, Sam, he's engaging independence and freedom in a way he's never noticed before, and two weeks it's deciding, and the third week he crashes, and you're like, oh my gosh, like that's not a line of code to be rewritten. That's not a theological proposition or doctrine that just needs to be reinstilled, you know.
SPEAKER_05No, and I went I went through that with all three of my kids, you know, when they went away and they're up in school and then they're calling up one day and they're excited about something that happened, and then the next day they're calling you up at you know, two in the morning, just completely broken down because of the stress. And it wasn't anything I could do to fix, but they just wanted to vent, they wanted to talk to dad, dad to listen to them and encourage them that they can get through it.
SPEAKER_02Um so, yeah, no, and I mean that's where the listening part where we we grow in our maturity and we listen. And you know, John Briniger put in the chat, one sows, another waters, and another reaps. And Jason, that I think that's what you're getting at, you know. Also, is you know, you you see one guy, he sows by walking out of the room, and you're like, oh, okay. And then another one can come in and water the conversation in a different way, and then another one reaps the harvest, you know. Maybe it's you at the end of all of that, Jason, that's now doing the reaping. You see what I'm saying? So that just worked itself out in our lives that way. But it all begins with Steve that listening and and recognizing I don't have to be the guy, I don't have to fix it. And boy, there's something to be said about the quiet, intelligent man. Jen, Jen uh is, you know, dealing with uh she's she's got a colleague in in the upper management level who's brilliant, but he likes everybody in the room to know that he's brilliant. So he does all the talking all the time. And I'm like, you know, you know, usually what happens is when you need everybody to know that you're the smartest person in the room, everybody actually is beginning to recognize that you have some significant competence issues, right? Versus the one that's actually listening to everything, waiting to hear everybody's point of view, and then responding with all the information they've taken in. That's a problem at the moment. Yeah, go ahead, Chad.
SPEAKER_01And I think your wife has the same manager that I do.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Chad, you're one of those guys, though. You you're what I call a you're a a lurking, you know, brilliant guy. You're always lurking around and listening, you know, and then you you you've taken in the conversation and and you share what you you've heard from it and what you want to respond with. And the guys like you, Chad, and some others that do that, you know, you're like, I can't wait to hear what you have to say because you don't chime in very often. So it must be something. But you you're a reflective dude.
SPEAKER_01Well, thanks. Yeah, I think that just with this thing like what he was saying earlier, there's the verse about throwing your pearls to swine, you know. And sometimes you talk to people and it's just you can it's just a waste of time. I mean, you can say what you want to say, but if they're not in a position or if they're not willing to listen at all and to interact with you on a rational level, then yeah, it's you're just wasting energy at that point. So it's better just to move on to someone else who's willing to listen and converse with you.
SPEAKER_02So and maybe maybe what they witness then is the calm presence of a man with the mind of Jesus Christ instead of somebody that wants to irrationally argue back about how you know you're right because you're a Christian.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because they have this perception of Christians that oh, perception, you know, Christians are all hateful and angry and all this kind of stuff. So if you calmly say, Well, nice talking with you and walk away, that breaks that perception.
SPEAKER_04Let's face it, we all grew up in the 80s action movies where men don't do that. Men are the first ones to go in with fists flying and make a point. So it's it's kind of ingrained in our nature sometimes to just stop and listen and not and to be calm is harder than to be a man of action sometimes.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_08No, we want to, yeah, we want we want to be the Rambo, right? We want to be the the action hero that comes and saves the day, that transforms uh the heart of this person that doesn't think like you. Uh instead of sitting with somebody and seeing them in the image of of God and and and trying to understand why it is, what it is that that led them to think the way they they do, to hear their story. And for me, when people when you know, before I even get to that, Andy, before I even get to talking about any of those deep things, um, I talk about the simple things. That's why I ask people, what's your favorite song? What's the song that you don't like? It starts with something simple to build a relationship. People don't like to be looked as a project. I don't want to be looked as a project. I'm not your what is that movie that she's all that, you know, or you're trying to transform me into the prom queen, um, you know, so I can be better looking. People don't want to be that. As soon as they find out, they're out. Really love people.
SPEAKER_02You know, and to get back to what what Dave was asking, especially as we're coming up on Thanksgiving and this stuff's gonna happen at your Thanksgiving dinner table. Uh, Paul says in in 2 Corinthians chapter 5, after you've been made a new creation in Jesus Christ, you are now ambassadors of reconciliation, not ambassadors of being right, not ambassadors of winning an argument, not ambassadors of fixing someone. You're now an ambassador of reconciliation, which means you're now an ambassador of reconciling somebody who's broken and has far apart from the Lord. Like your job is simply to reconcile as much and as best as you can a broken relationship, not win an argument, not fix a project. You know, so that's just different. Reconciliation is uh a beautiful, loving thing, but you're not always going to be that guy. And and and that's just something that that takes a mature, a lot of mistakes, by the way, along the way to that maturity of thinking, you're the guy. But I also, even in being an ambassador of reconciliation, I don't think it's my job to get somebody reconciled to God. My job is to, uh, when I can proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ, and then it's the Holy Spirit's job to reconcile them to the Father. So it's not even my job to do the reconciliation.
SPEAKER_08No, and that's one thing that we do have a lot of evidence of what happens when we try to force somebody to change. The church has done atrocities trying to force people's heart to be transformed by the gospel. It does not work, it won't work. And I love what Jeff Pressler says. I always like quoting that because I heard it from him. Um, he says, um, he was telling me about he was arguing, and then he realized, you know what? I'm trying to be right, uh, and I want to be righteous. I don't want to be right.
SPEAKER_02Well, and when we're trying to be right and we're trying to win an argument, we're self-righteous, which is ugly and broken and sinful. We're not righteous from an external point of view that's been given to us as a gift, the righteousness of God. This is why Romans 1, 16 through 17 hit Martin Luther so hard and kicked off the Reformation, is because he had now recognized that righteousness was an external gift given to him, not one that he earned on his own. Because I now know that the righteousness of God, God's righteousness, is given to me by faith as a gift. Self-righteousness is something we muster up in ourselves, and it's ugly and it's hypocritical. And this is the righteousness of the Pharisees, right, Obi? Where they want to look good and they want to win arguments, but they don't actually care about the person in front of them. You know, sitting in the temple praising, oh God, thank you that you didn't make me like Obi, because he's, you know, eats, you know, peanut butter and jelly in his tacos. You know, and all of a sudden you're pointing at somebody else with they don't do life as good as you do, right? That's the self-righteousness of the Pharisees that's hypocritical, but it's not the righteousness of God.
SPEAKER_08Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And that's, I think, what we see on social media, what we hear when we watch the news, what we're seeing all the time is we're seeing the self righteousness of Pharisees. We're not seeing the righteousness of God that comes to us as a gift that we didn't earn and Don't deserve. I'm not I'm not witnessing that a lot when I watch social media or the news or what's going on in the world today. I we are surrounded by self-righteousness.
SPEAKER_08Well said, Andy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_08Well, if you guys hang just two or three more minutes, um, I just want to go over these seven main principles of critical thinking.
SPEAKER_02These are really game, they'll be a good place to stop, and we'll get into the skills again next week. I know this is a lot and it's taking some time, but man, it's good information. If you could hit the those principles today, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_08Yeah, you it's it's it's an it's it's no, we want that. Yeah, great conversation. Uh, this is kind of nerdy, guys, but it's it's important. Okay, this is actually good stuff. So these are the seven main principles that serve as a core rules that guide rational discourse and objective evaluation.
SPEAKER_02So, exactly what you just asked about, Dave. Here's seven main principles of how to deal with it.
SPEAKER_08Yep. Uh, the fallibility principle. Everyone must remain open to the possibility that their initial position, belief, or assumption might be wrong. Truth-seeking principle. The primary goal of the inquiry must be honest exploration to determine which position or argument is backed by the strongest evidence, which is usually not how heated emotional, prejudicial-based arguments take place. The clarity principle, arguments, concepts, and language must be expressed as clearly and transparently as possible to prevent confusion. What do you mean by that orange man?
SPEAKER_02Literally, Dave, I think CJ said something along those lines. What do you mean by that orange man? What is it that's getting you so upset? I need to know what those things are because I don't know what that orange man means.
SPEAKER_08Yep. Gotcha. The burden of proof principle, the responsibility of providing valid evidence falls on the person making a claim rather than forcing others to disprove it.
SPEAKER_02Now that that's a you you better responsibly provide valid evidence for your conversation instead of because I know. You know, and instead of pointing to somebody else that said it on a you know propaganda channel that you're more aligned to than the other. You better have really valid evidence for why you believe what you believe.
SPEAKER_08All right, and finish with these three. The principle of charity, an opponent's are oh, an opponent's argument should be interpreted in its strongest, most rational form rather than distorted or exaggerated. Again, avoiding Strawman fallacies.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so you know, you gotta understand the that coming at the point of view of giving charity to their argument, they believe in it. What are the strongest, most rational points of it? Steal their argument for them. Steal is in hardened, know their argument better than they do. And instead of setting up another human being as a straw man to not down, you better know where they're coming from really well. But we don't take the time to do that. We like strawmen because we look awesome. We look like Rambo, we look like the last, you know, action hero when we knock somebody else's straw man down. Yeah, that's why we like creating straw men.
SPEAKER_08The suspension of judgment principle, you should withhold the final conclusion or belief until sufficient and reliable evidence has been gathered.
SPEAKER_02Be okay with walking away. I don't know what has gotten into us, especially when it comes to religion and politics, that we believe that we have to win the argument, settle it, close it, and then we can walk away from it. And bel, I don't know where we got in our minds that we didn't truly understand that you can walk away from something and let it sit and come back to it at another time.
SPEAKER_08The comment section on social media. That's what that's what that's that's what's programmed people to do that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So you you do have the right suspension of judgment principle. Walk away from it and think about it for a while.
SPEAKER_08Yep. Uh, and the resolution principle and argument or position should be accepted if it is proven sound and successfully counters objections or abandoned when it's decisively refuted.
SPEAKER_02And can I give you guys a quick secret? You are going to get in conversations with people where they are right and you are wrong. Welcome to being a broken, sinful human being. Are you okay with actually hearing somebody else's point of view, recognizing that they've proven it soundly and successfully with proper evidential objections, and you can go, you know what? I think I was wrong about that. This resolution principle, Obi, is phenomenal for a strong marriage, by the way. Sometimes, I know this is we're getting insane now. We're gonna stop here. Sometimes your wife is right, and all God's men said, Amen. Yep, amen.
SPEAKER_05Well, I said no.
SPEAKER_03Now, now wait, wait.
SPEAKER_02No, knowing yeah, knowing Steve and knowing Tom, knowing like he's not here, yeah, knowing Tom though, like this is why the WLC might be beneficial for for us too, is that maybe our wives should be going through the same conversation, going, oh, you mean my husband right sometimes?
SPEAKER_08It doesn't it's not often, but fall apart just on that. Yeah, yes, yeah.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. Obi, you want to finish this up with a prayer?
SPEAKER_08I would love to. Lord, we thank you so much because we have someone to we're not going in this blindly trying to grow up our way around the around our society, around the way things are right now. We have a a prime model, a perfect example of somebody that took time to critically think, to under to understand people, to understand those different than him. Um, he met them where they were, um, and he was able to articulate things in a winsome manner. During this season, Lord, I pray more than anything that you allow us to take time to step back, understanding that there is a good chance that we might be wrong, but with a desire to be righteous more than wanting to be right. So I pray that you continue transforming our minds day by day, and that you allow your word and that you allow the gospel of Jesus Christ to transform us and allow us to not just be people who listen to your words or who read your words or who put on podcasts or watch movies that are Christ-centered, but are actually transformed by those weary words that you said.
SPEAKER_00We love you, and it's in your name we pray. Amen. Thanks for joining and listening. We hope that you were truly blessed. Now you can join the live call every Friday morning at 7 a.m. Central Standard Time, and please bring a friend. And to learn more about the MLC, visit our website at the mlc.life. That's the mlc.life. Have a great day.