The Men's Leadership Community
THE MEN'S LEADERSHIP COMMUNITY
- For men seeking personal growth and heroic leadership at home and work
- For Men who are beat up, broken down & burned out from doing life alone.
Join a Brotherhood where Good Men become Heroic Leaders....at home, at work & in the world.
You can join the call live every Friday morning via Zoom @ 7:00am Central
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
The Men's Leadership Community
The Godly Thinking Man, Part 5: The 8 Core Skills of a Thinking Man
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This is where thinking gets practical. In Part 5 of The Godly Thinking Man series, Andy and Obie move from the rules of critical thinking to the actual skills, the ones that change how a man handles every conversation, from the boardroom to the Thanksgiving table.
At the center are the eight core skills every thinking man can practice: observe, ask good questions, analyze, evaluate, interpret, synthesize, infer, and reflect-and-communicate. The guys pair them with Socrates’ rules for clear thinking; define your terms, question assumptions, demand evidence, test consequences, spot contradictions, steel-man the other side, and admit what you don’t know and then raise the bar with the intellectual standards (clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, depth, breadth, logic, significance, fairness) and the intellectual traits of a mature mind (humility, courage, empathy, autonomy, integrity, perseverance, confidence in reason, and fair-mindedness).
But this isn’t a philosophy lecture, it’s modeled on the greatest thinker who ever lived. You’ll walk through Jesus and the rich young ruler (Luke 18) and see how he led with a question instead of a verdict, and through Paul at the Areopagus (Acts 17), where Paul listens, learns the culture, and even quotes the Athenians’ own poets to point them to Christ, never straw-manning, always reasoning. The takeaway for us: when you share your faith, some will sneer, some will want to hear more, and some will believe and you need to be ready for all three.
Along the way: why “you think you’re thinking when you’re just rearranging your prejudices,” why proof-texting people isn’t winsome, how to keep your conversation “full of grace, seasoned with salt,” and why real critical thinking is a mark of Christian maturity. Scripture woven throughout: 1 Thessalonians 5, Colossians 2 & 4, Isaiah 1, Ephesians 4, Luke 18, Acts 17, 2 Peter 1, 2 Timothy 1, and Colossians 3.
If you want to stop reacting and start thinking like Christ and actually reach the people in front of you, this is the toolkit.
🎧 Join the live call every Friday at 7 a.m. Central. Bring a friend.
🌐 themlc.life
Part 5 of 8 — Critical Thinking Series. (Part 6 goes deeper into intellectual standards and traits.)
Get more information here...
https://themlc.life/
Men. Welcome to the most important podcast that you'll hear in a long time. It's the Men's Leadership Community Podcast, and it starts now.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, we're continuing our series. We're speedballing towards the end of our series, The Godly Thinking Man, um, where really we're talking about critical thinking, right? And how and how vital it is, and and we are taking it, taking all our notes and our are modeling it after the greatest think critical thinker of them all, uh, Jesus himself, who asked those questions. You know, I know if you were there last night, you know, we had somebody that had a, you know, a question, and it almost everybody was like, Why do you want to know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, no, it's making its way through. We had I had several guys that it was really cool. They're like, man, this isn't just a great series for the MLC, but I w they were like, I wish this was nationwide that people had to go through this kind of training. And and it is, it takes time to get through it. Uh, we are we are, I mean, critical thinking, we're picking apart piece by piece, Obi, but it does really begin to actually change the way you think and the way you process stuff. Even if you were on the WhatsApp chat that was going on throughout the day yesterday, I mean, guys were critically thinking through movies. Uh, so it was interesting to see that it's taking hold in a couple of different ways already.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Uh, so it is great to see that. You know, it it's uh it's really and the reason why we prayed about this and getting this because you know that there's this reality of navigating our our current culture, right? More and more as we're surrounded by um by entities, applications, apps, uh, all of these things that are that are competing for our um our attention, bombarding us with with with um things that you should think about. Um, you know, it can seem like a maze. And we have this illustration of a man just standing facing a maze. Um, and that's on us on our own, trying to navigate through all of that on our own. It's it's almost impossible. It is impossible. Um, but with Christ, with the mind of Christ, now we're able to have a vision, to have a direction, and to really hopefully be able to uh take a step back and look at things from a Christ-centered perspective and hopefully have conversations that are winsome, right, with people. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and really grow our ability to talk about any subject matter. That was one of the great uh scripture verses we've had the last couple of weeks. It's not on for today, but it says to be able to think through all things in Christ, not just like the churchy stuff, not just the Sunday morning stuff, but every aspect of your life from a Christ-centered perspective, Obi.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and if you have not been to our happy hours, that's one of those opportunities that you actually get to see that put in practice, right? Because now we're having people asking sometimes difficult questions. We've had some difficult questions before, and and people can actually see what that looks like or when we as brothers get together and begin to think um about things in a different way with the mind of Christ.
SPEAKER_02These are these are three great verses right here, guys. Take a screenshot of this. Three great verses that talk about what it means to be a follower of Jesus and have critical thinking and navigate our current world today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. First Thessalonians says test 521 says, Test everything, hold fast what is good. Um, and then first John 4.1 says, Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world. And then Colossians 2.8 says, See to it that no one takes you captive by philosophy and empty deceit according to human tradition, according to the elemental spirits of the world, and not according to Christ.
SPEAKER_02And Obi, I think those are three great verses that put those two images side by side that you just had a minute ago of trying to go through the maze on our own, which is impossible, versus having the cross, you know, walk us through the maze and be able to get to the other side of it. That you you you know, just to be able to line that up with scripture. Scripture is telling us to be critical thinkers, not blind faith, thinking faith.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I talked about that. I shared with you guys how that was something that I grew up listening into is you got to just have blind faith and and correct theology, guys. All right. Um uh we talked about the the last thing really that we left off on last week was the same main principles um of critical thinking that we kind of put on here and just kind of go over them really quick so that we can move on and continue to what we had this week.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and these connect directly to what we're gonna go to next. So I wanted to do just a quick review, OB, because the the seven main principles, you know, how you know, having the know the rules is gonna tie into the practice then.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Uh we got the fallibility principle. Everyone must remain open to the possibility that their initial position, belief, or assumption might be wrong. Well,
SPEAKER_02that's a tough
SPEAKER_01one. Yeah. There's a truth-seeking principle. The primary goal of the inquiry must be honest exploration to determine which position or argument is backed by the strongest evidence. Um, the clarity principle, arguments, concept, and language must be expressed as clearly and transparently as possible to prevent confusion.
SPEAKER_02You know, Obi, we even saw some of this happening last night and some of the questions uh, you know, that guys were asking, especially we were talking about some biblical questions about Jesus, and we saw this at work, uh, you know, in the conversation, even, you know, as we not necessarily disagreeing, but learning with one another. Uh, and it was all very, very open-handed, very fair in the way that we were discussing through some of those things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, there's the burden of proof principle. The responsibility of providing valid evidence falls on the person making the claim rather than forcing others to disprove it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, the principle of charity, an opponent's argument should be interpreted in its strongest, most irrational form rather than distorted or exaggerated. And we talked about the avoiding strawman fallacy. Uh, the suspension of judgment principle, you should withhold a final conclusion or belief until sufficient and reliable evidence has been gathered.
SPEAKER_02You know, and that's the tough one for a lot of us is that suspension of judgment principle because I think oftentimes when we sit down with somebody else, we already have a response prepared before we even hear the end of their sentence. You know, and that's part of what the suspension of judgment principle is listen to someone, seek to understand the point that they're coming from uh before you begin with a response that's some kind of uh, you know, propositional parroting of something you are you heard, and you just want to make sure you cram that in before they finish their argument. So there's a lot of patient listening that happens in critical thinking before you can actually bring about your response.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And then um, last, the resolution principle. An argument or position should be accepted if it's proven, sound, and successfully counters objections or abandoned when it's decisively refuted.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, really good. So these are great, these are great rules to go by just in any kind of general conversation. These are rules that we see uh not being applied at all uh in the public sphere right now. Uh, we we see people screaming over one another. We see people defending a prejudicial position without listening to the other side, and it's become commonplace that we are not seeing critical thinking at a wide level in our country or in our culture.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm glad you mentioned uh prejudicials because uh I like this quote by William James that says a great many people think they are thinking when they are merely rearranging their prejudices.
SPEAKER_02What a powerful statement. You think you're thinking, but really you're just moving your prejudices around to win another argument. And William James is actually the philosopher that coined the phrase critical thinking in the early 20th century. Uh so really good guy to pay attention to.
SPEAKER_03There's also another William James quote that says, There is great power in knowing what to not respond to.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, for sure. Yeah, what to not waste your time on. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's see what the Bible says about uh season reasoning. This is from Isaiah and Colossians. Um, Isaiah 118 says, Come now, let us reason together, says the Lord. Though your sins are like scarlet, they shall be as white as snow. Though they are red like crimson, they shall become like wool.
SPEAKER_02What I love about this verse, Obi, is this is God calling for us to come and reason with him, which means that we are out of our minds. That's what he's trying to say to Isaiah in chapter one. All of Israel is out of their mind. Why don't you come and let us reason together and I'll help you with your thinking because it's way off. Uh, and so it points out, you know, our sinfulness, like Scarlet, but God is going to reason with us in our forgiveness of sins in order to bring us back to thinking that is more white as snow. So I really like the fact that God actually cares about our thinking.
SPEAKER_01He does. Um, and if you want to go New Testament, Colossians 4 6 says, Let your conversation be always full of grace, seasoned with salt, so that you may know how to answer everyone.
SPEAKER_02Wow. Now that that's a big ask right there, so that you may you may know how to answer everyone, uh, especially with the gospel of Jesus Christ. But the gospel of Jesus Christ is full of grace and seasoned with salt. And I wonder how many times, Obi, we present ourselves and we present Christ in such a way that is without grace and with and not seasoned with salt.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and do
SPEAKER_02more than we know.
SPEAKER_01You know, and Andy, and I think you and I talked about this, um, why it's so important for uh, you know, we we both feel the same way that it's it's so important for for as believers to learn really critical thinking way before um they kind of get into the apologetics part of it, where you, you know, you're trying to you're trying to slam the the the ball, you know, into somebody and they just ace them, you know, just oh I got the perfect scripture for you, pow pow pow pow pow and then all forgetting that they're our conversation should be full of grace and seasoned with salt.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Proof texting people with verses that are pulled out of context is not winsome thinking.
SPEAKER_01No, not at all.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So um let's get into these critical thinking, these eight core skills that we have here. Uh these
SPEAKER_02are so huge, oh, because now we're actually getting into the practice. How do you actually practice critical thinking? So we've gone through the rules. These are the core skills that we need to really not only practice and not alone, but what we're doing right now with everybody on the call and at happy hour and all of the retreat, the the Christmas party is to be doing this with one another.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and these are important because they allow you to objectively analyze information, cut through bias and misinformation, very relevant today. Make well-founded choices to clearly and succinctly communicate them with others. So here we go. Start observation, the ability to notice and predict opportunities, problems, and solutions.
SPEAKER_02Now look at the difference in those three right there. And when it comes to, you know, are you able to notice opportunities? Are you able to notice problems and are you able to notice solutions? So it's not just like pointing your finger and blaming. That's not an observation.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Asking good questions, the ability to ask formal and informal questions to seek deeper understanding and productive dialogue. This also includes questioning assumptions in order to look beneath the surface of claims to see what is taken for granted.
SPEAKER_02You know, and that we did that last night with the questions during an open mic session. And some of the questions seemed kind of straightforward and easy that you would just simply, you know, is this a sin or is it not? And you would just answer, yes, that's a sin, instead of asking good questions of the human being that's standing in front of you and why are they asking that question.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. You know, and I think this is one of those, this is why it's so important to have the face-to-face conversation and and why so, you know, the um the comment sections, you know, in in media posts and everything are so toxic because they remove this ability, right? For you to actually, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Go ahead. No, no, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for it it it it removes the productive dialogue.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, and that that's what I was gonna say is it it it it this right here uh gets rid of the whole idea of like straw man, I'm gonna knock him down, like you were just saying on social media, and it takes us away from the theoretical realm and the ideology, ideology realm. So you're getting rid of uh the theoretical and the ideologues, and you're actually now dealing with how you should communicate in dialogue with another human being. But what we see in the public right now is everything is based on the theoretical and everything's based on ideologies, and nothing gets done.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So you grease out the old sausage fingers, you know, and then you get away on your keyboard and then, you know, spout your venom. Um, analysis, the ability to gather, understand, and interpret data and other relevant information. It is also the practice skill of breaking down the whole into parts to be further examined. This includes assessing the credibility, strength, and relevance of sources and data.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that's a huge, that's a huge skill is to be able to break down the whole into parts and look at the individual parts. And then if we're to do that, we're gonna find out one of the skills is then now we have to be able to synthesize and put all those parts back together in a whole and see what it looks like.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, evaluate the ability to assess the value or quality of the conversation, the present data, and the relevancy of the information at hand. This includes recognizing biases by identifying personal prejudices, emotional influences, or flaws in logical reasoning.
SPEAKER_02You know, and this this could be the one where Dave Terry just spoke a minute ago about, you know, there are some arguments, there are some conversations, there are some dialogue that just isn't worth our time. And we can evaluate that at this moment and say, you know what, I'm I got an Irish goodbye. Uh, you know, I'll be back in a minute. And then let that conversation go because it's not worth the emotional strain that it's going to put on you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh, interpretation, the ability to clearly and succinctly explain the nature and meaning of the discussion as well as the significance and value.
SPEAKER_02You know, and that's such a big one. We don't stop and actually define terms with people anymore. Like, what do you mean by that? What is your understanding of that, you know, this conversation? And to be able to clearly and succinctly explain the very nature of what we're discussing with one another so that at least we know we're talking about the same subject matter. We may be coming from different perspectives, different points of view. Maybe we even come to the recognition, Obi, that we're working with different different definitions, but at least that's a start.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Uh, synthesize the ability to recombine the parts to form a coherent whole. This includes weighing alternative viewpoints before reaching an independent conclusion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So a course,
SPEAKER_01yeah, now we're having to put everything back together.
SPEAKER_02Coherently, a coherent whole. And this is, I think, a struggle when we talk about all the time about compartmentalization, fractured, splintered humanity. This is very challenging for us, and I would say impossible without the work of the Holy Spirit to actually now form coherent holes, holistic thinking, and seeing things, you know, in that manner, because our very broken, sinful nature is to compartmentalize, fracture, and splinter things and keep them separated from one another. We do it with ourselves when we look in the mirror, you know. So this is a challenge for us.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Infer the ability to draw meaningful conclusions based on the data and relevant information in light of one's personal knowledge and experience. Uh, reflect and communicate, the ability to self-regulate regarding one's conclusions in order to adjust your own thinking, recognize yeah, recognize biases and course-correct your analytical strategies in order to reach logical and credible conclusions that can clearly and succinctly be communicated with others.
SPEAKER_02And this one right here at the very end, this reflect and communicate, Obi, this ability to self-regulate regarding our own conclusions and adjust our thinking is a growth mindset. So we're looking for men that want to have a growth mindset instead of a static mindset. Like, I I don't need to learn anything else. I know what I know, it's right. Uh that is just, you know, what's that old phrase? If you're not, if you're not growing, you're already dying. I mean, that that this is a growth mindset to do critical thinking, and that's exactly what this says here at the end with reflect and communicate.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we always want to point it back to scripture. This is out of Ephesians 4 15, 29. In regards to these beneficial skills, instead, speaking the truth in love, we will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head that is Christ. And then verse 10.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we see that once we see that once again on the maturity side. Critical thinking is a a sign of maturity and growing in our thinking in Christ.
SPEAKER_01Do not let any unwholesome talk come out of your mouths, but only what is helpful for building others up according to their needs, that it may benefit those who listen.
SPEAKER_02So you mean all of a sudden my growth mindset and wanting to grow and becoming a critical thinker is not just for me, it's to benefit other people too. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So Socrates, Socrates, Socrates, however you want to say it, um, these are some of the seven critical thinking rules that he kind of conjured up. So he
SPEAKER_02got him in a lot of trouble, by the way. You know, he made the youths, he made the youths of the day think, and it got everybody upset.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I'm gonna go over them. One, define terms. One of the rules, the rule is most arguments are about words, not ideas. Agree on meaning first.
SPEAKER_02You know, and CJ just put that in the chat. There's so many politically charged words that people just throw out there that we've not even agreed on what we mean by them or how we define them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02They're actually used as weapon, you know, a little grenade bomb. I'm gonna throw this word at you that this is what you are.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Uh ask, what exactly do you mean by that? Can you give me give me an example or how would we measure it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and we did that last night again. What you know, what what why is this important to you? Why are you asking? What do you mean by that? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, two question assumptions. The weakest part of any idea is a part nobody says out loud. What are we talking? What are we taking for granted? What has been true for this to work? What if it turns out wrong?
SPEAKER_02You know, and that's funny because in social media today, you know, you see on all of these reels that are coming out for 15 seconds, and in the tag phrase is he just said the quiet part out loud, you know, and it and it kind of aims at this assumption and weakest link kind of deal.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Demand evidence. Confidence is not evidence, neither is repetition. Ask how do we know this? Where does this data come from? What would change your mind?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and right there you kind of get into the concept we talked about the last couple of weeks of epistemology. How do we know what we know and where does that knowledge come from? And that's demanding the evidence from the other person is where is your knowledge coming from? What's the source? What's the authority of it? And then you got to know your own. You have to know your own epistemology and why you know what you know, how you know it, and where it came from. And for us, we're talking about the source being God's word, Jesus at the center, the way that we read it. Uh, that's our hermeneutic, that's the key. Uh, that's our worldview. So we've got to understand our own epistemology, Obi, and why we're thinking through things the way that we do when somebody else in front of us is thinking through them from a different worldview.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh four, test consequences. Bad ideas look great on day one. Check day 90. Ask ask what happens if we act on this. And then what? What's the most, what's the worst realistic outcome?
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_01All right. Five, spot contradictions. If two claims can't both be true, someone is wrong, maybe you. Ask, does this fit with what we saw said before? Where does this clash with the facts? Which of the two do we actually believe?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then this really brings up an even deeper thought of like uh uh being dial dialectic is actually now you're going into an even deeper stage. Can two things that we think are mutually exclusive both be true? And that's when when you're really getting into deep critical thinking, Obi, Jesus understood this. Uh Paul understood this, Luther understood this. There can actually be two claims that seem mutually exclusive. That actually can take place together. And are we thinking through that deep enough that that can be true, such as this one right here, saint and sinner at the same time? Can that actually be true? And the answer is yes. So you're getting to that deeper now, uh, not only spotting contradictions, but are we in our critical thinking enough that we can actually handle mutually exclusive ideas and figure out whether they can be true at the same time or not?
SPEAKER_01Dick Steelman, the other side. Make the best case for the other side. If you can't, you don't understand your own. Oh man.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a tough one, man. This is the one that we don't want to do. You mean you want me to understand and make a case for the side that I don't agree with? And the answer is yes, because that's how you begin to understand not only their side, but we understand why we're coming from where we're coming from and why it's so important.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So now we ask, what's the strongest case against this? How would a smart critic see it? What else could explain this?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this takes time and it takes humility and it takes the actual effort to think through what the other side is thinking. We're just trying to talk about, maybe just trying to talk about how we how we think about our own thinking. Now we're being called into the process of actually thinking about why other people think what they think.
SPEAKER_01And last but not least, admit you don't know. The wisest man in Athens knew one thing, how much he didn't know. What ask what we what don't we know yet? Where could we be wrong? Who knows more about this than we do?
SPEAKER_02And don't be afraid to say, uh, well, that's a great question. I don't know the answer to that. I do that all the time with people, especially when they believe it or not, when they ask me questions about the Bible, I'm like, I well, I don't know the answer to that. Let me go take a look at it and I'll get back to you. There's absolutely nothing wrong with admitting that you don't know that you'll do some research and you'll reconnect with somebody.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Well, again, well, this is out of Luke 18, 18 through 30. Uh David.
SPEAKER_03Helps build understanding if you say it in front of somebody who's gently questioning proposing you. You know, I don't know. Let me let me research that or let me get back to you. Because it's open, honest, and vulnerable. And that's a probably thing to do. Especially if we're trying to really build understanding with us.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. You know, and Obi in this in this particular, we're gonna get an example of Jesus' critical thinking, of him actually following uh, you know, Socrates' model, and that Jesus actually used something similar, it's his own, but it comes from the same kind of setup of asking good questions, thinking through things, both sides, and this is a really powerful one from Luke chapter 18 on Jesus beginning with asking good questions and then processing through the thought, not only that he has, but that the person in front of him has. Yep.
SPEAKER_01A certain young ruler asked him, Good teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life? Why do you call me good? Jesus answered. No one is good except God alone. You know the commandments, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not murder, you shall not steal, you shall not give false testimony. Honor your father and mother. All these I have kept since I was a boy, he said. When Jesus heard this, he said to him, You still lack one thing. Sell everything you have and give it to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come follow me. When he heard this, he became very sad because he was very wealthy. Jesus looked at him and said, How hard is it for the rich to enter the kingdom of God? Indeed, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich, rich to enter the kingdom of God. Those who heard this asked, Who then can be saved? Jesus replied, What is impossible with man is possible with God. Peter said to him, We have all left all we had to follow you. Truly I tell you, Jesus said to them, No one who has left home or wife or brothers or sisters or parents or children for the sake of the kingdom of God will fail to receive many times as much in this age and in the age to come, eternal life.
SPEAKER_02You know, and we miss the we miss the point of this over and over again because we don't think through scripture critically with critical thinking, Obi, and we go, Oh, Jesus said that to be rich you can't get into heaven. That's absolutely not what he said. Uh, what he is pointing out is that uh this line here in verse 27, what's impossible with man is possible with God. And he was trying to bring the rich young ruler to understand that there were all different kinds of aspects of ways that he was trying to inherit eternal life and be with God. And all of them are impossible. And the only possibility of being with God for eternity is through the man standing in front of him who is Jesus Christ. Now, for this rich young ruler, what he was helping him to understand, Obi, was that he had something that was blocking him from being able to see Jesus for who he was, and that was his wealth and wanting to hold on to it. But the greater interpretation through critical thinking is we all have something in front of us that prevents us from seeing Christ for who he is. And without God, it's not going to be revealed to us. It's going to prevent us from continue to prevent us from being able to see Jesus. So even in this moment, Jesus is trying to remove what's in the way. You know, so uh the the the whole point of it though is verse 27. We get so wrapped up on the money side or the wealth side, because that's just where our broken human thinking goes, versus Jesus is pointing out to everybody that can hear him what is impossible with man is possible with God. And what's impossible for man is to inherit the kingdom of heaven by doing stuff. It's only possible with Jesus doing stuff for us.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh Andy, we have this um image that's the critical thinking circle.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so this is the updated of Socrates' version. So this is the Dr. Richard Paul and his wife Laura Elder. Uh, and this is the critical thinking circle that they came up with based off of Socrates. So this is just kind of an update of his uh thinking into the modern world and the way that they started to define and teach critical thinking that I think is pretty powerful. So you can see kind of the order of things and how they flow. And I like that they've actually got it more um of coming back around to the beginning, Obi.
SPEAKER_01So we got observe, start with a curious mind.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, again, an another one that I don't think we do very well. Are we are we even curious anymore? You know, with the immediate information and data at hand in our smartphones, I don't know how curious we are. We just want information and data. We want an immediate answer instead of doing the discovery. And a curious mind wants to discover things. So we need to be curious and we want to have you know that journey of discovery in our critical thinking.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, we got questions asked to understand, and gather information, seek knowledge broadly, analyze, break it down, synthesize, connect the dots, decide, choose with confidence, reflect, think back to move forward, and then reevaluate, adjust, and improve.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, really good. So, this is another one you might take a screenshot of. It's very helpful uh when we get deeper into the weeds, probably next week, of how this actually plays out in even more kind of information on when it comes to you know uh intellectual standards and and traits, characteristics of being a critical thinker.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Moving on. This is out of Acts 17 through 34.
SPEAKER_02And hopefully what you'll see in this, Obi, uh all the guys at, you know, they just saw that circle of critical thinking. Hopefully, you'll see Paul doing this. Uh, this is a great, you know, a great example again from Acts 17 of Paul actually going through critical thinking with others.
SPEAKER_01Yep. While Paul was waiting for them in Athens, he was greatly distressed to see that the city was full of idols. So he reasoned with the in the synagogue with both Jews and God fearing Greeks, as well as in the marketplace day by day with those who happened to be there.
SPEAKER_02Sounds a lot like our world today. A lot of idols all around everywhere, people from different backgrounds. So, what does Paul do? He reasons with them. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01A group of Epicurean and Stoic philosophers began to debate with him. Some of them asked, What is this babbler trying to say? Others remarked, He seems to advocate foreign gods. They said this because Paul was preaching the good news about Jesus and the resurrection.
SPEAKER_02He's a he's babbling about this Jesus guy rising from the dead. Then
SPEAKER_01they took him in and brought him to meet to a meeting of the Aeropagus where they said to him, May we know what this new teaching is that you're presenting?
SPEAKER_02Now
SPEAKER_01you're bringing
SPEAKER_02this real quick real quick before we beat these guys down over the head. Hey, they're curious. They're asking questions, they're critically thinking, they want to know what he's talking about.
SPEAKER_01May we know what this teaching is that you're presenting? You are bringing some strange ideas to our ears, and we would like to know what they mean. I'll go ahead, Andy.
SPEAKER_02No, I just love it. I like, do we even give credit to those that we're sitting down with that maybe they're critically thinking better than we are at times? You know, and you have these people that don't know Christ, but they do they do love knowledge, they love learning, they're curious and they want to discover, they're asking great questions, and they not only not only do they want to know, but then they ask him, define this for us. What does this mean?
SPEAKER_01All the Athenians and the foreigners who live there spent their time doing nothing but talking about and listening to the latest ideas. Paul then stood up in the meeting of the Aeropagus and Aeropagus and said, People of Athens, I see that in every way you are very religious. Whereas I walked around and I looked carefully at your objects of worship, I even found an altar with its inscription to an unknown God. So you are ignorant of the very thing you worship, and this is what I am going to proclaim to you. The God who made the world and everything in it is the Lord of heaven and the earth, and does not live in temples filled by human hands, and he is not served by human hands as if he needed anything. Rather, he himself gives everyone life and breath and everything else. From one man he made all the nations that they should inhabit the whole earth, and he marked out their appointed times in history and the boundaries of their lands. God did this so that they would seek him and perhaps reach out for him and find him, though he is not far from any of us. For in him we live and move and have our being. As some of your own poets have said, we are his offspring. Therefore, since we are God's offspring, we should not think that the divine being is like gold or silver or stone, an image made by human design and skill. In the past God overlooked such ignorance, but now he commands us all people everywhere to repent, for he has set a day when he will judge the world with justice by the man he has appointed. He has given proof of this to everyone by raising him from the dead. When they heard about the resurrection of the dead, some of them sneered, but others said, We want to hear you again on this subject. At that, Paul left the council. Some of the people became followers of Paul and believed. Among them was Dionysus, a member of the Auropagus, and also a woman named Demaris and a number of others.
SPEAKER_02There is so much in here to unpack regarding critical thinking. So Paul has has not only listened to them, but he's walked through in the Areopagus and he's seen all of the idols that are there, even one to an unknown God. He's listened to them, and now he begins to provide evidence as he defines who Jesus is. And then he provides evidence from the beginning. He's the creator of all things all the way up to today. So he's prepared with good evidence. But here's the amazing thing: even as he's giving the evidence, Obi, he's citing some of their own poets who wrote poems about Zeus. And he's taking that poetry about Zeus, which is an idol, and he's now applying that poem to the true God, Jesus Christ. So he knows their culture, he knows their thinking, he doesn't just straw man, he uses their arguments to prove who Jesus is. And then at the end, here's the amazing thing. Some of them sneer at him and walk away, and others want to know, like, would you talk about this more? And then some of them believe. Well, guess what's going to happen in our conversations with people? Some are going to laugh at us and sneer at us. Some are going to say, I need to hear more about this at another time. And some are going to believe and say, I want to go with you. And, you know, we need to be prepared for all of those different responses, just the way that Paul was. So go back and look at this again, and you're going to see just a brilliant scriptural exposition of Paul's critical thinking with some very, very intelligent people. Make no mistake that just because they're idol worshippers, that they weren't smart, they were very intelligent. They were talking about ideas all day long, right? But they just didn't know the full truth. Well, that reminds me of our world today, Obi. Just because somebody is in front of you and is not a believer in Jesus Christ and is either a secular person worshiping themselves or worshiping our culture, whatever, does not mean that they're not intelligent. It means they don't have the wisdom of God. That's what they don't have.
SPEAKER_01But
SPEAKER_02it doesn't mean that you can't talk with them in a reasonable way.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So now we're going from the theoretical now to the practical application, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because we we're we're not just doing this so that you can have like a like a repertoire that you can kind of ponder upon later and recall 10 years from now. But something that you
SPEAKER_02and these are challenges, Oli.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. These are challenges, Obi, to us to we're being challenged to practice them regularly. Okay. And then all of a sudden, here, look at what these three are. These are these matter, Obi, that we actually have intellectual standards on how we process our thinking. Uh, that we have actual key elements of reasoning, and then we have intellectual characteristics or traits that we are carrying out in front of others.
SPEAKER_01Uh, so we have intellectual standards, key elements of reasoning, television's press of characteristics, and now the standards that Andy is talking about. Now we have uh clarity.
SPEAKER_02So this is breaking it down even more now. To do we actually have these standards with the way that we think?
SPEAKER_01Is my thinking easy to understand?
SPEAKER_02Ask your wife.
SPEAKER_01Uh-huh. Accuracy. Accuracy, is it true? Um, precision, is it exact and specific?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and you know, that we've seen in the chat this morning already with a lot of the political conversations that are going on in the way that names of or terms without definitions are just splattered across the page at somebody. It is not exact and specific thinking that we're seeing in public today.
SPEAKER_01Nope. Um, relevance, does it relate to the issue at hand? Uh depth, does it address the complexities? Breadth, does it consider other viewpoints? Logic, do the ideas make sense together? Significance, is it important to focus on this? And then fairness, am I being just and unbiased?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then that's a really big one. So when we get down to that, being fair in our thinking with other people, uh, you know, on the human level, uh, when we're when we're spending time with another human being, allowing them to be able to share their side, listen, uh, and then be just and unbiased in the way that we respond. So take a screenshot of these guys. This is pretty huge because I would I would really advocate that this is not the kind of intellectual standards that we're seeing at play in our culture today.
SPEAKER_01No, not at all. Um, it's actually the opposite. It's keywords to make you uh react, which is you know, creates engagement, and that's what really ultimately all they care about.
SPEAKER_02Well, just look at some of the look at some of the major issues that we're talking through in the world today. And I'll just pick one because it's a hot topic, so I don't want to get into it, but I want you to apply these intellectual standards to the conversation about gender. And you tell me if these intellectual standards are being used in the public sphere very well. So uh this is just important clarity, accuracy, precision. What is a woman? What is a man? Be exact and specific. And what we see a lot in in the conversations in our culture today is well, it could be this or it could be that, you know, and there's a lot of room to flip-flop on even definitions. So this stuff is pretty important, guys, not only to understand our own thinking, but to understand the thinking of others. So
SPEAKER_01yeah, and I'm putting, you know, I'm I'm posting these questions. There's another slide that we have here that kind of gets you some questions as far as like clarity, accuracy, precision, you know, uh that you can kind of look through clarity. Could you elaborate? Could you illustrate what you mean? You know, when it comes to accuracy, how could we check on that? How could we find out if that's true? Precision, could you be more specific? Could you give me more details? Could you be more exact?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and the precision is the peeling of the onion, Obi. This is where we're asking the questions to actually get down to the core aspect of the issue at hand, which we rarely do. So we talk about surface level things instead of getting down to the core issue.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh and then uh relevance, how does this relate to the problem? How does this bear on the question? Uh, depth, what factors make this difficult? What are some of the complexities of this question? What are some of the difficulties we need to deal with?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Breast, do we need to take a look at this from another perspective? Do we need to consider another point of view? Do we need to look at this in other ways? Um, logic, does all of this make sense together? Does your first paragraph fit with your last one? Does what you say follow from the evidence? Uh, significance? Is this the most important problem to consider? Is this the central idea to focus? Which of these facts are more important? And then this last one. Fairness, is my thinking justifiable in context? Am I taking into account the thinking of others? Now it's just taking it outside of your own thinking, but uh thinking about others. Is my purpose fair given the situation? And am I using my concepts in keeping with educated usage or am I distorting them to get what I want?
SPEAKER_02So look at these questions, guys. The deep when you break these down even deeper, you ask your question and ask this, ask this question of yourself, not just of an opposing side of an argument, but are we using these intellectual standards to critically think through how we share our faith in Jesus Christ? Wow. Now all of a sudden, we've got a little deeper work to do in the way that we share our belief, our faith in the Son of God. Are we clear about it? Are we accurate? Are we precise? Are we relevant? Do we have depth, breadth, logic, significance, and fairness? Or are we just cherry-picking proof texts in order to win an argument with somebody to show that Christianity is right and true and they're wrong? So all of a sudden we're questioning our own thinking about our own faith and a very positive growth mindset.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's see what uh 2 Peter 1, 5 through 9 say about that. For this very reason, make every effort to add to your faith virtue, and to virtue knowledge, into knowledge self-control, into self-control, perseverance, into perseverance godliness, into godliness mutual affection, and to mutual affection love. For if you possess these qualities in increasing measure, they will keep you from being ineffective and unproductive in your knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ. But whoever does not have them is nearsighted and blind, forgetting that they have been cleansed from their past sins.
SPEAKER_02Man, and he's talking about Christians. Here's the deal: we can either grow in these intellectual standards and qualities that would keep us from being ineffective and unproductive in our knowledge of Jesus Christ, or we can just go on being nearsighted and blind. I mean, this is a very powerful set of verses in 2 Peter. Uh, a guy who had to grow in his critical thinking. So if you don't remember Peter, he was kind of a blunderbuss, just running headfirst through doors. And later in life, now after Christ's resurrection, he's growing in his ability to be a critical thinker.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think that's pretty positive stuff.
SPEAKER_01Well, Andy, let's talk about some elements of reasoning.
SPEAKER_02Nice.
SPEAKER_01Um, and just by the way, guys, if if you're not part of our WhatsApp channel, shoot me a message because I'm posting all of these in our WhatsApp, WhatsApp chat. These are these are important.
SPEAKER_02This goes to last, yeah. This goes to the last night, Obi Guys saying, Man, why is this not being trained, you know, nationally in our culture about how to think with one another? So I think it's got some traction and pretty important. What we're doing here on a Friday morning with like 30 guys, uh, that this stuff ought to be done across our entire culture and globally.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we got purpose. What am I trying to accomplish? The question at issue. What is the central question I am address I am addressing? Um, information. What data, facts, or evidence am I using? Interpretation and inference, how am I drawing conclusions, concepts? What theories, definitions, or principles am I using? Assumptions. What am I taking for granted? Implications and consequences. What follows from my reasoning? And then, last but not least, point of view. From what point of view or worldview am I seeing this issue?
SPEAKER_02You can go back to Acts 17 and lay this out over what Paul did with the men in the Areopagus, Obi. Almost
SPEAKER_04the
SPEAKER_02almost block for block. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_04Sorry, when you're saying being taught nationally, do you mean from a church perspective and education, you know, education perspective? What do you what for what what do you mean is because for people and the people in power don't want us to think critically, right? They want people to be sheep and just do what they want. So are you just speaking from a church perspective taught nationally?
SPEAKER_02I think that's where we would have our beginning audience. Yes, I think this should be taught throughout Christianity nationally, globally, but I think it could have wider uh implications. What if we what if we intentionally tried to make inroads into uh the the schools, the high school, you know, elementary schools, middle schools, high schools, centers, our universities and colleges of higher learning, that this was a course that had to be taken by all. Like we don't make that argument, but the other side from things are making arguments about what our children, what our kids have to take. And this would be one of those that might be something that we would say, hey, this has to be a core course. So, but I think our I think our opening audience, Dave, yes, is is we're not even doing this in our churches to begin with.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, well, we got these elements of thoughts.
SPEAKER_02So this is all the same stuff of you just kind of now put with, you know, that we love to have that circular view with, you know, Jesus at the center.
SPEAKER_01Um and we got point of view, purpose, question. It's and I'm posting these right here because I think these are these are some um uh beautiful, beautiful reference slides that we can actually go back and look at uh through. Um we just got a few more slides, guys. I think we're just gonna go just a little bit over, but it's okay. Um, 2 Timothy 16 says, For this reason I remind you to fan into flame the gift of God, which is in you through the laying of my hands. For the Spirit God gave us does not make us timid, but gives us power, love, and self-discipline. So do not be ashamed of the testimony about our Lord or of me, his prisoner, that are joined with me in suffering for the gospel by the power of God. He has saved us and called us to a holy life, not because of anything we have done, but because of his own purpose and grace. This grace was given us in Christ Jesus before the beginning of time. But it has now been revealed through the appearing of our Savior, Christ Jesus, who has destroyed death and has brought life and immortality to light through the gospel. And of this gospel I was appointed a herald and an apostle and a teacher.
SPEAKER_02So, real quick, godly purpose. I hope you guys didn't miss it, okay? But because of his own purpose and grace, guess whose purpose we are sharing the gospel? It's God's purpose, not our own. And that that's another thing, Obi, that makes our critical thinking different from worldly critical thinking is because worldly critical thinking, everybody's thinking about their own purpose. Why am I arguing this? I'm arguing this for myself. But for us, it's God's purpose in Jesus Christ and through his grace. So we have a very different purpose in the way that we not only critically critically think, but in how we share it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, so we got some intellectual traits of critical thinking.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and this is the last one, guys. Hang in there, we're almost done.
SPEAKER_01Yep. We got humility, knowing you could be wrong and being open to learning. Uh, courage, willing to question ideas even if unpopular. Uh, empathy, genuinely considering another's perspective, autonomy, the ability to think for oneself, not parroting another. Integrity, holding yourself to the same standards you expect from others. Aye. Perseverance, sticking with complex problems to resolution, confidence and reason, trusting sound logical, rabias, or impulse. And last, fair-mindedness, treating all viewpoints equally without initial favoritism.
SPEAKER_02And you can just see some of those in there, Obi, that we really struggle with humility, autonomy, integrity. We really struggle with those three, I think, and when it comes to our thinking and and you know, conversations with somebody that doesn't agree with us. I think humility, autonomy, and integrity are the things that are gonna break down at the Thanksgiving table in a in about a week. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I've determined after looking at this this uh all this complicated thinking that from here on out I'm only gonna have conversations with my dog.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think your dog's picked it up by now, so he may be asking
SPEAKER_02you
SPEAKER_01some difficult questions.
SPEAKER_02You know, but Michael, you you bring up a great point. It's very it looks very complicated in the way that we're presenting it, but as we work through it and begin to practice it one with one another, Michael, it actually makes our thinking easier. The challenge is actually going through it to the point that it becomes second nature to think this way. But once we begin to think this way, Michael, it actually our thinking becomes much easier because it's getting rid of all the distractions.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02But it takes time. It again, patience, growth mindset, wanting to do the hard work, the hard work of thinking, you know. So, and it's only after 20 some odd years that uh now a lot of this for me is is becoming uh very natural, second nature to me, Michael. But it took a lot of work, a lot of research, a lot of thinking, a lot of wrong steps along the way.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So I got two more slides. This one critical thinkers routinely apply intellectual standards to the elements of reasoning in order to develop intellectual traits. So we got the standards of clarity, accuracy, relevance, logicalness, breath, precision, all the things we just talked about, death, fairness that must be applied to the elements, purposes, questions, points of view, information, implications, assumptions. That way, Nandy, you just got there talking about as we learn to develop these intellectual traits, right? Intellectual humility, intellectual autonomy, intellectual integrity, courage, intellectual perseverance, uh, confidence in reason, intellectual empathy, and fair-mindedness.
SPEAKER_02And what I love about this slide, Obi, that's just a little different, is it says we must apply this in order to grow in practicing it. So you got to put it to work.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're gonna end with Colossians 3:12 through 17, and then I'll close us out in prayer. Therefore, as God's chosen people, holy and dearly loved, clothe yourself with compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience. Bear with each other and forgive one another if any of you has grievance against someone. Forgive as the Lord forgave you, and over all these virtues put on love which binds them all together in perfect unity. Let the peace of Christ rule in your hearts, since as members of one body you were called to peace, and be thankful. Let the message of Christ dwell among you richly as you teach and admonish one another with all wisdom through psalms, hymns, and songs from the Spirit, singing to God with gratitude in your hearts. And whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I love that, Obi. Let the message of Christ dwell among you richly, but the peace of Christ be alive in you as you teach and admonish one another. So Christ at the center of our critical thinking.
SPEAKER_01And Lord, that you would transform our thinking, that you would give us the mind of Christ, that you will allow us to dwell on things that are good, that are wholesome, that are winsome, that are edifying with one another, that you allow us to see people in the image of God, that you allow us to understand and empathize and with humility be able to have deep conversations that have meaning, that point towards you, that proclaim your goodness, that proclaim um the good news of Jesus Christ. And I ask you and I plead with you, Lord, that everyone that's here, that you allow us to be men who not just listen that one ear and out the other, or just read a passage and shelve it with the rest of the you know things that we know, but that are actually transformed by the power of the gospel of Jesus Christ, but that are transformed by the words in red. Change our hearts, change our minds. And it's in your name we pray. Amen.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for joining and listening. We hope that you were truly blessed. Now you can join the live call every Friday morning at 7 a.m. Central Standard Time, and please bring a friend. And to learn more about the MLC, visit our website at the mlc.life. That's the mlc.life. Have a great day.